Replication Data for: Conflict Management Trajectories: Theory and Evidencedoi:10.7910/DVN/XRJE8UHarvard Dataverse2020-10-221Owsiak, Andrew, 2020, "Replication Data for: Conflict Management Trajectories: Theory and Evidence", https://doi.org/10.7910/DVN/XRJE8U, Harvard Dataverse, V1, UNF:6:MmAldvvBV/twLamXR89/Gg== [fileUNF]Replication Data for: Conflict Management Trajectories: Theory and Evidencedoi:10.7910/DVN/XRJE8UOwsiak, AndrewHarvard DataverseInteractions, InternationalInteractions, International2020-07-30Social Sciencesconflict management, Mediation, Peacekeeping/Peacebuilding, ConflictWhen multiple attempts to manage a given conflict occur, are these attempts interdependent—and if so, how? Policymakers and practitioners regularly report that such interdependence exists; and yet, explicit theorizing about it remains underdeveloped. The need for theorizing motivates the current study. Using the concept of a conflict management trajectory as a foundation, I develop four models that potentially link successive conflict management efforts together: a cost model, a limited cost model, a learning model, and a baseline model. I then test these models' predictions empirically with data on diplomatic interventions during the period 1946-2000 (i.e., verbal pleas, mediation, arbitration, adjudication, humanitarian and other administrative tasks, and peace operations). The analysis shows that the limited cost model best explains interdependence among conflict management attempts. In that model, states balance their desire to do something with their incentive to minimize costs. This creates an intervention ‘threshold’ beyond which third parties less frequently travel—particularly if that threshold has not yet been crossed in a given dispute. Third-party intervention overwhelmingly resides on the less costly end of the spectrum, exceeding the costs associated with mediation rarely. If a third party crosses that threshold, the probability of further intervention on the high-cost side of the threshold rises, but third parties still prefer to return to low-cost conflict management strategies. It seems, therefore, that rational considerations dominate, as third parties work to achieve the benefits of peace for the lowest possible price.<a href="http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0">CC0 1.0</a>Replication Data for Trajectories - Theory and Evidence.tab267955text/tab-separated-valuesUNF:6:MmAldvvBV/twLamXR89/Gg==Unique CM Attempt0.00.4779731985500622.1061.01.00.64750235626767221618.01.0UNF:6:Bq6RQTMO+PnXUnrRn2R70w==Precipitating MID1706.10531237808644339.0.1363.00.07.02679.02274.678611422183UNF:6:P9I6kSxfhMTQRCHcRA/hPQ==2679.0393.263531168351342.0959.00.048.0.442.8124825225027UNF:6:EbNCPm/Q3Ibo5U6d0NVzQQ==1.016.04.4061054564882262679.05.0429264650989260.03.0.UNF:6:+dtCO58s0jF2JA2RxEl4+w==15.3710348420931081.017.31056364315045256.0.12.02679.00.0UNF:6:Tc7obP47o5IZuihL2jaPIw==Int Type 1=verbal, 2=mediation, 3=legal, 4=admin, 5=peace op0.0.0.94698790042799255.01.02679.01.01.507652108995893UNF:6:CCgOoaO9n4xeUGf5iFV5PQ==Exact strategy type (Frazier and Dixon 2006)2679.01.1000000238418580.0.0.96127338437461075.51.20000004768371581.7205673827302677UNF:6:fbxLnNQQH/r3AxraCVSNew==0.014930944382232018.0.00.00.121299231014165722679.00.01.0UNF:6:90XNM0oF4hdCEAKsqtkxZQ==Attempt ever achieves short term success Y=1/N=01.02616.00.36200305810398020.00.00.4806715760726670363.0.UNF:6:P7s71ym8rBLyKHduWx/xTw==0.346947027901332862473.00.01.00.4760949949319883206.0.0.0UNF:6:r2aP005ubeN922FkfV3HSQ==2679.02816.00.02040.0.820850.0294753.3142320934250236.83128032682UNF:6:sEy4W5ntMTpbI7EKOEGNLQ==2679.0249.5808137364703294.7533470022303.820.00.02.02.0UNF:6:2UzQU/7Q3kRyA/2urYIO4A==850.0.184.06049854771481645.02679.0646.685703620755540.00.0UNF:6:dPgXny3Ohch5gQvgfimAvw==.690.0690.0561.00.0690.02118.0690.0UNF:6:g9CRqJODXmUem5WMXfM17g==745.78312803284812305.02679.00.0423.3938119693753750.0.2.0UNF:6:augECSuUx8QnqNX2zfQ+NQ==Start month of CM2674.01.06.03.68847794859034512.05.0.6.304038893044125UNF:6:rYzFgRufrU+8gLkTOjIfAg==Start day of CM15.01.094.0.2585.015.15899419729209431.09.0333843626681UNF:6:oHBbnBr5GjKy1WCyOQ8n2g==Start year of CM.1946.00.016.340876854468452001.02679.01973.01979.8566629339307UNF:6:g57QVd+vGImjRIIMlVuKtA==1.01.0207.0.0.458597093161997540.00.69943365695793092472.0UNF:6:HLq7Jla80xtGI2wK2hEt3w==1.00.9397249190938509.1.0207.02472.00.00.2380439418037265UNF:6:+aLxMCegEmgUfSzysL0Wug==.0.228057976959844370.00.94498381877022632472.0207.01.01.0UNF:6:U0YiDzJWqFZaAeaNw1XTdA==0.17592367511982218.1.02472.0207.01.00.96804207119741130.0UNF:6:qcTvvIeQZd16XHRGVwrtbQ==Disputants contain a major state Y=1/N=0).1.00.58790593505038970.00.4923037825368490.02679.01.0UNF:6:zgrsRFDNjKwhXzX+n/yTCg==Disputants are enduring rivals Y=1/N=00.0.2679.00.3896924342127970.18663680477790090.00.01.0UNF:6:ISwXWle3MA8+8oNG+aeF/A==390.0720.70000000000022.0.355.491671902133362289.0999.01206.0UNF:6:6oateb4R+J0IeRzwggLKxw==20.02507.0172.0380.0418786914984999.0.1200.0732.4709302325581UNF:6:5v4hJRqp68YHdhuTSEu34w==999.02552.0.822.2834645669292127.0328.0298.81902198322751206.0UNF:6:eAUH8kaXZWjiD3B6h/sL3w==2593.0.286.25014268301516211.0999.0865.093023255813986.01200.0UNF:6:ORQySYtYu5I3wPz9Ns5xHA==2676.0550.0325.0.389.7114317029974325.01000.03.0UNF:6:gPDFe+phh5yIosqUXFh84g==Weaker:Stronger Disputant CINC ratio2679.00.26442548642501743.80609038984403E-40.00.04371831938624382.0.22307839483945560.9712865948677063UNF:6:66xJPqXebwk4A55IExx1Kw==Post Cold War Y=1/N=0.0.00.01.02679.00.00.49445933371973240.42515864128407105UNF:6:5WqIToKIjlStGoWq3675hg==IGO Intervention0.01.02679.00.474812830951445050.0.0.00.343038447181785UNF:6:TrkPMihW4t+IRof00RSWJw==Coalition Intervention.1.00.02679.00.087346024636059560.282394164009734270.00.0UNF:6:fVRCL9CkmoQVXJjrHDiZ8w==State Intervention1740.0.0.0939.01.01.01.01.0UNF:6:B5Egt8BBcv4D622/2J1VgA==Max Pct of Single TP Code's Strongest Member (Ind States Agg)0.138368010520935060.172923830523511620.14287143657937938.537412213627249E-52265.00.9875061511993408.414.0UNF:6:m2Wx9V5QvlXDKWP45MPTOQ==Max % of Single TP Code's Dems (Ind States Agg)0.41122339811603172452.01.00.37053444451040146227.0.0.00.2526595741510391UNF:6:XOPqOwYvURo7mpRNL5V5pw==Fatality2509.01.74502199084646136.0170.0.0.06.05.220406536468717UNF:6:SFVxky6NQkSr8ribuktikQ==HostLev.3.04.05.00.50079798476804855.04.7065420560747672675.0UNF:6:MXhkhe9cIUucAti1cBBNUA==0.56040508885209140.8516715168952942820.00.143890099670534180.5597150325775146.0.179307103157043461859.0UNF:6:TYHXVNDHngEFoyDoi00Nrw==0.45630881190299990.349356934428215820.01859.00.079696918605778460.136060968041419980.3359445596795258.UNF:6:Rb2uo7P9+xGqSTX8c015SQ==0.0285471528768539430.0118344135057158480.011796054430305958.0.0053541144576869571859.0820.00.0023462027311325073UNF:6:MBA8uuLYzaCdm0SyYtuS1Q==.0.09835044294595718820.00.0051477546803653240.033637702465057370.019540066360714730.036128615566938231859.0UNF:6:TszmiinGMV581NtufIOxrw==0.0441321595101564.0.045684177428483960.004613612778484821820.00.055687321946819881859.00.26709723472595215UNF:6:jlOIzlMKj/yuD7nUdCv/nQ==0.8857111334800720.5550962686538696.0.102022893726825711993.00.16841009336337867686.00.5480787770024367UNF:6:WEY1hmNKOhFFmyLspBS8tA==0.343570426421419330.35657162964344025686.00.47688552737236023.0.093666680879463031993.00.10690145194530487UNF:6:DPYDOl7oMQX9243Mm9nIyQ==0.011080920366019170.0101055298000574110.0274549107998609541993.00.0013583148829638958686.0.0.005943578019116523UNF:6:pC2SmUWZW0VfvBNKOp6cGQ==686.00.00359696941450238230.043045420498307535.0.1311340332031251993.00.0269433025271684120.03806847333908081UNF:6:qP+wX7W+zLqq9GNAfXmzCw==.0.051734808949792564686.00.00234189885668456550.35909870266914370.0385802350938320160.0542244561781574861993.0UNF:6:x+nSJb1PZPQOImyFVpmSoQ==Ycat== 1.0000.1.00.01.00.47015588306807250.67039940276222352679.00.0UNF:6:zpsnbSkmDN/l1SBmVNU3xQ==Ycat== 2.00002679.00.4369565018685280.25681224337439310.0.0.00.01.0UNF:6:O9AfnjFmySjSlDFkvsFi9w==Ycat== 3.00000.086095910523550330.00.00.01.0.2679.00.007465472191116013UNF:6:n1ZSS7BxnFf3Ajxqpg50pA==Ycat== 4.00000.01.00.0253826054497949572679.00.0.0.00.1573135925589852UNF:6:5xGGeRf42nhqPxvZOrIJZg==Ycat== 5.0000.0.01.02679.00.195855480132440090.0399402762224715450.00.0UNF:6:wpZBl/49LZIf6RJyd6ecdg==esample() from estimates store0.01.00.25606569615528480.4365400200558134.2679.00.00.0UNF:6:14mPWU8PCnu7BKvtT+iQ+g==esample() from estimates store0.00.00.25606569615528480.0.0.43654002005581341.02679.0UNF:6:14mPWU8PCnu7BKvtT+iQ+g==Log File for Trajectories - Theory and Evidence.smclapplication/x-stata-smclReplication Do File for Trajectories - Theory and Evidence.doapplication/x-stata-syntax