Manipulating morality: Third-party intentions alter moral judgments by changing causal reasoningdoi:10.7910/DVN/TAWE7FHarvard Dataverse2020-11-191Phillips, Jonathan; Shaw, Alex, 2020, "Manipulating morality: Third-party intentions alter moral judgments by changing causal reasoning", https://doi.org/10.7910/DVN/TAWE7F, Harvard Dataverse, V1, UNF:6:AKyQI8nxipzbAZVfWyhfbA== [fileUNF]Manipulating morality: Third-party intentions alter moral judgments by changing causal reasoningdoi:10.7910/DVN/TAWE7FPhillips, JonathanShaw, AlexHarvard DataversePhillips, JonathanPhillips, Jonathan2020-11-16Social SciencesThe present studies investigate how the intentions of third parties influence judgments of moral responsibility for other agents who commit immoral acts. Using cases in which an agent acts under some situational constraint brought about by a third party, we ask whether the agent is blamed less for the immoral act when the third party intended for that act to occur. Study 1 demonstrates that third‐party intentions do influence judgments of blame. Study 2 finds that third‐party intentions only influence moral judgments when the agent's actions precisely match the third party's intention. Study 3 shows that this effect arises from changes in participants' causal perception that the third party was controlling the agent. Studies 4 and 5, respectively, show that the effect cannot be explained by changes in the distribution of blame or perceived differences in situational constraint faced by the agent.<a href="http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0">CC0 1.0</a>Study1.tab7820text/tab-separated-valuesUNF:6:VQTBHtJBxz5KnkOJVSfitw==Study1_data-1.tab7820text/tab-separated-valuesUNF:6:VQTBHtJBxz5KnkOJVSfitw==Study1_data.tab7813text/tab-separated-valuesUNF:6:2sITcLSg4gOdJgG5KucPng==Study2_data-1.tab33411text/tab-separated-valuesUNF:6:Xy5lMHYjFlQHRizv9OGTLw==Study2_data.tab15911text/tab-separated-valuesUNF:6:qoRBJLl7yBpHPbMBh6npQg==Study2_data2.tab17511text/tab-separated-valuesUNF:6:AA6ZfFB+PmCVLEuUiB4vNg==Study2_data3.tab33411text/tab-separated-valuesUNF:6:Djcx0Lt/9wFgCSwLZYrHyQ==Study3_data-1.tab12515text/tab-separated-valuesUNF:6:OuARTLy6F6RqzvHAodGveA==Study3_data.tab12514text/tab-separated-valuesUNF:6:TYDcLTyyuWnpISNjGwEk4Q==Study4a_data.tab19325text/tab-separated-valuesUNF:6:7YpAGTIWLPMYUg7HEC9w9w==Study4b_data-1.tab40524text/tab-separated-valuesUNF:6:pJwVpd1UpSQoaStYpGQtvA==Study4b_data.tab40519text/tab-separated-valuesUNF:6:thgAiYBsBgsyPRbWXSsDBg==Study5_data-1.tab30022text/tab-separated-valuesUNF:6:78VO3Fpk3+tJ/1Mkh3XaYQ==Study5_data.tab30022text/tab-separated-valuesUNF:6:sTBnm/0W6PY+QOXKrr6qUg==UNF:6:+FKCB5F8yz+zNn+ZVSY5Fw==0.0.0.00.078.00.00.00.0UNF:6:iXtE5fOQGQErAJNOo/Jlnw==UNF:6:lFrGKE+WyfhZKze9cgbAOw==UNF:6:Z6277WooQnmrQptIECYhtw==78.01.0.0.01.00.93589743589743590.2465209134587990.0UNF:6:RFWkaFh1QcRQVbMEUFPUpw==0.05198066.51188717.09981342.078.05269589.6410256412469653.8120785374.UNF:6:LVadbxWnxDweBMrhPGPprQ==1.01.078.00.01.01.00.0.UNF:6:iNLtLDKCLdPvlzkqxDIq0Q==0.00.5025741264537530.47435897435897430.0.0.078.01.00Accidental411Intentional37UNF:6:O1eTFpBxM4TRhZ9ffpz9tw==451.8650.041.03253.163206251697611.078.78.051.15911538461538UNF:6:GzDWhlfknmrolq6xpcF2fw==7.01.62548181847449245.04.858974358974359578.0.1.00.0UNF:6:8G0oPuHs63TMZ/CBD7WITA==0.07.0.5.6282051282051296.078.03.01.2495087279695414UNF:6:6FVeiBShA4BCzhektivxlQ==0.01.0.78.00.88461538461538460.32155342230584830.01.0UNF:6:k10nlRfXsNbNHPKs5cfv2Q==UNF:6:DL9mWYwSDFMzo22fPoF61w==27.078.0.18.00.058.030.1410256410256428.653089470007659UNF:6:fy/Hf0C1rzXe4jibj5vYOg==1.078.01.01.4358974358974360.02.00.499083408945087.UNF:6:1QmlQdDdrXUMzq5ZFqshlg==1.14696025019083141.00.06.05.0.78.04.551282051282051UNF:6:baJm/kKTWrf7gydQiqbnMw==.8.02.00.04.04.47435897435897451.306570398840493878.0UNF:6:G0bNAQ9iq2RFGqCCTqOIXg==.5.7307692307692316.01.77041397259670161.00.078.010.0UNF:6:U+Q1hdJs/FH0145gvL8CoA==UNF:6:lwTznVCyW35sFxsx/0nr5w==Control=1 (FILTER)0.88461538461538460.01.0.78.00.32155342230584830.01.01Selected690Not Selected9UNF:6:k10nlRfXsNbNHPKs5cfv2Q==UNF:6:+FKCB5F8yz+zNn+ZVSY5Fw==0.00.00.00.00.0.0.078.0UNF:6:iXtE5fOQGQErAJNOo/Jlnw==UNF:6:lFrGKE+WyfhZKze9cgbAOw==UNF:6:Z6277WooQnmrQptIECYhtw==0.24652091345879978.00.00.9358974358974359.1.00.01.0UNF:6:RFWkaFh1QcRQVbMEUFPUpw==78.09981342.02469653.81207853745198066.55269589.6410256411188717.0.0.0UNF:6:LVadbxWnxDweBMrhPGPprQ==0.01.00.078.01.0.1.01.0UNF:6:iNLtLDKCLdPvlzkqxDIq0Q==0.5025741264537530.078.00.47435897435897430.00.01.0.1Intentional370Accidental41UNF:6:O1eTFpBxM4TRhZ9ffpz9tw==51.1591153846153841.032451.86578.0.0.01.07853.16320625169761UNF:6:GzDWhlfknmrolq6xpcF2fw==0.04.85897435897435951.07.01.6254818184744924.5.078.0UNF:6:8G0oPuHs63TMZ/CBD7WITA==3.06.0.78.00.07.01.24950872796954145.628205128205129UNF:6:6FVeiBShA4BCzhektivxlQ==0.00.88461538461538461.078.00.0.1.00.3215534223058483UNF:6:k10nlRfXsNbNHPKs5cfv2Q==UNF:6:DL9mWYwSDFMzo22fPoF61w==27.078.00.08.65308947000765930.14102564102564258.018.0.UNF:6:fy/Hf0C1rzXe4jibj5vYOg==.0.4990834089450871.01.4358974358974360.078.02.01.0UNF:6:1QmlQdDdrXUMzq5ZFqshlg==78.0.5.01.01.14696025019083140.06.04.551282051282051UNF:6:baJm/kKTWrf7gydQiqbnMw==1.30657039884049384.02.078.0.0.08.04.4743589743589745UNF:6:G0bNAQ9iq2RFGqCCTqOIXg==78.010.01.77041397259670160.05.7307692307692316.01.0.UNF:6:U+Q1hdJs/FH0145gvL8CoA==UNF:6:lwTznVCyW35sFxsx/0nr5w==Control=1 (FILTER)0.00.00.8846153846153846.1.00.32155342230584831.078.01Selected690Not Selected9UNF:6:k10nlRfXsNbNHPKs5cfv2Q==IPAddressUNF:6:+FKCB5F8yz+zNn+ZVSY5Fw==Consent1.01.01.078.01.0.0.00.0UNF:6:iNLtLDKCLdPvlzkqxDIq0Q==Condition1.00.078.00.47435897435897430.00.00.502574126453753.UNF:6:O1eTFpBxM4TRhZ9ffpz9tw==Time0.078.01.078.41.03251.1591153846153853.16320625169761451.865UNF:6:GzDWhlfknmrolq6xpcF2fw==Proximal1.62548181847449240.0.5.07.078.01.04.8589743589743595UNF:6:8G0oPuHs63TMZ/CBD7WITA==Distal7.01.2495087279695414.0.05.6282051282051293.06.078.0UNF:6:6FVeiBShA4BCzhektivxlQ==SummaryUNF:6:4yStOxoxIEz0Oqsnpc5LkA==Age78.030.1410256410256428.6530894700076590.018.0.58.027.0UNF:6:fy/Hf0C1rzXe4jibj5vYOg==Gender1.00.4990834089450871.4358974358974361.078.02.0.0.0UNF:6:1QmlQdDdrXUMzq5ZFqshlg==Ethnicity6.00.01.04.551282051282051.5.078.01.1469602501908314UNF:6:baJm/kKTWrf7gydQiqbnMw==Education1.3065703988404938.4.47435897435897454.078.02.00.08.0UNF:6:G0bNAQ9iq2RFGqCCTqOIXg==SES.5.7307692307692311.00.01.770413972596701678.06.010.0UNF:6:U+Q1hdJs/FH0145gvL8CoA==Condition_TextUNF:6:lwTznVCyW35sFxsx/0nr5w==UNF:6:ePiPpTRbBRAfJOSZbGD+iA==.0.00.0334.01.01.01.01.0UNF:6:YpesaSKOT9hJ08lWpQFNcw==1.7242102669794428.1.07.04.0778443113772460.0334.04.0UNF:6:XjLop8x1EH9ZV2CUABGLuA==7.0.6.0329341317365271.18883409277865636.0334.00.01.0UNF:6:bdup5HKE16n1C+Dh79Dhxw==UNF:6:x4kSZ0SrkkEKQw4aLUCpVQ==21.072.032.1405750798722112.07824579411657418.0.313.028.0UNF:6:SCnFRvGJKP8B+yqZPCMnnw==17.01.02.0.0.4914311875199252317.01.40378548895899051.02Female1281Male189UNF:6:qRodKY8U1IL9cgRnxzK+rg==.18.04.3639240506329125.0316.01.29853242458763776.01.02Hispanic/Latino121Black/African American264Native American/American Indian23Asian/Pacific Islander325White/Caucasian239UNF:6:9dz6JZnfMDKwsmQPsLEGMA==4.2848101265822784.018.08.01.0.316.01.26286030672827022Highschool or Equivalent398Professional Degree (JD,MD,etc.)81Grammar School29Other05College Graduate (4 years)973Vocational/Technical School97Doctoral Degree (PhD)44Some College1366Master's Degree21UNF:6:CbOzPvW8YT/XxVJMsP1pZQ==1.77162962256879496.3714285714285712.019.0315.0.10.06.0UNF:6:oDHlLz1+WC1Wv8MQ3+EV0g==.1.01.4940119760479051.00.02.00.5007142764520793334.01Consistent1692Deviant165UNF:6:gWKpgH04Z9MhPtdsTUW50A==IPAddressUNF:6:OilFCFAeIcFRzoV26cZwJA==Consent1.00.01.0.1.0159.00.01.0UNF:6:Tlfxh5nKnonzdP2/Hi8VBg==Blame_Prox0.07.01.0159.04.201257861635224.01.6905540781987376.UNF:6:QfnxLbGCbUhtvy/XXiBdAQ==Blame_Dist6.01.1692256444309357.7.0159.06.00.01.0UNF:6:H0q0SIeI1mSkGDpuB1ZCkQ==SummaryUNF:6:Og40oyrGZerXqPh5mkdRvw==Age28.010.899761343863656.156.03.030.9102564102564165.018.0UNF:6:2NTqxpnynJ0UJieYv0NWgA==Gender1.0158.0.2.00.49119474023773641.01.39873417721518981.0UNF:6:FW0dTdyPJ6xoJOp9BsO7OA==Ethnicity2.06.04.554140127388535.157.01.01.14575529035071495.0UNF:6:dBC1SjUmqd/Adf6f93f4wQ==Education1.08.04.299363057324841157.01.2478955010124072.04.0.UNF:6:8Wsx8opa41UtRWCRnZHPKA==SES156.0.6.1282051282051293.03.06.010.01.8200246319423155UNF:6:PDgTHSba4BrtRQDonurbyA==Condition1.02.01.4905660377358494.0.5014904939758341.00.0159.0UNF:6:3oMFTyDHVWerdva1JQ7Eug==IPAddressUNF:6:dmAFk7FU16oTEVT+PqDYZw==Consent175.01.0.0.01.01.01.00.0UNF:6:nG/4W12KT2lYgF/S4CRwRA==Blame_Prox0.04.03.96571428571428537.0175.0.1.75150884988672641.0UNF:6:+u+2ouzSYHl5jMUC6WMIKQ==Blame_Dist7.01.2089431392573046.0628571428571437.0175.02.0.0.0UNF:6:8PiRBS1GxEFiRgvguRS8jQ==SummaryUNF:6:bae5VmZ9wwDB/Xm7heC0Jg==Age.72.033.3630573248407613.0654922612484918.029.018.0157.0UNF:6:iLONhP0vJNqy1/cZufTbTg==Gender1.0.1.00.493166422188823159.016.01.4088050314465412.0UNF:6:APVx1DfiDJISLYUSSYfuBw==Ethnicity5.06.01.01.4121291546113612.16.0159.04.176100628930818UNF:6:UAooAXq/Ud3KIBvWLuDotw==Education1.28124511529143661.0.16.04.08.04.270440251572326159.0UNF:6:OvMdKl1OnWL8/ql3ahJ2dg==SES6.61006289308176110.02.07.016.0159.01.6947870546403132.UNF:6:zumjnPXj4AvTAx1vcQyQCA==Condition175.01.00.01.4971428571428576.1.00.50142653642240782.0UNF:6:wEsLXDMlPpYhj0HVIXhCXA==IPAddressUNF:6:ePiPpTRbBRAfJOSZbGD+iA==Consent1.00.01.00.01.0.1.0334.0UNF:6:YpesaSKOT9hJ08lWpQFNcw==Blame_Prox1.72421026697944281.0334.07.0.0.04.0778443113772464.0UNF:6:XjLop8x1EH9ZV2CUABGLuA==Blame_Dist7.06.0.0.06.0329341317365271.1888340927786563334.01.0UNF:6:bdup5HKE16n1C+Dh79Dhxw==SummaryUNF:6:3kpTvV+3JYYc0hOFxKqcaA==Age32.1405750798722128.021.0.72.012.078245794116574313.018.0UNF:6:SCnFRvGJKP8B+yqZPCMnnw==Gender1.017.02.0317.00.4914311875199252.1.01.4037854889589905UNF:6:qRodKY8U1IL9cgRnxzK+rg==Ethnicity5.0.1.29853242458763771.06.018.04.363924050632912316.0UNF:6:9dz6JZnfMDKwsmQPsLEGMA==Education1.26286030672827024.04.284810126582278.316.01.018.08.0UNF:6:CbOzPvW8YT/XxVJMsP1pZQ==SES315.02.010.0.6.019.01.77162962256879496.371428571428571UNF:6:oDHlLz1+WC1Wv8MQ3+EV0g==Condition2.01.00.0.334.00.50071427645207931.01.494011976047905UNF:6:gWKpgH04Z9MhPtdsTUW50A==1.036.228441865473663.0.0.0125.063.0125.0UNF:6:3b0qfJJ8xDPsYdC9dLqbPQ==0.00.0.1.01.0125.01.01.0UNF:6:1/+mJY4HXLkInuZm6rhTRw==0.50070917449089562.01.46400000000000041.01.0125.00.0.1Accidental672Intentional58UNF:6:VfUWB7jnvGKBhO4XjVLU5A==125.05.00.01.01.5960839172699364.663999999999999.7.0UNF:6:GJsxJ3biUP3gzDUhZMtH2A==7.04.8720.01.59624559513879245.0125.01.0.UNF:6:Eh4FpE3i8d6YDdqA9oq7Cw==1.68224120858780710.07.01.04.03.5520000000000005.125.0UNF:6:F86SbhR2h3jRHuJe47UU4A==1.38456934028762855.01.0.7.0125.04.9520.0UNF:6:zo8UghW+XCJbLq+BD57Y4g==47.942912125.040.3430.93635.651425324856326.261.660.0UNF:6:s0v3ao7Wz8xJ9XtA4D4dyw==UNF:6:MogKdEfz6N09TPub1QqfLw==124.0.18.071.028.011.0968928391915361.031.07258064516129UNF:6:5i8+6W99U5IYU0Hr2IUi9w==0.49722674863437332.0123.01.01.43089430894308942.0.1.02Female531Male70UNF:6:OrXD8C+/keI/UnabFdUBPg==0.9473415811284257124.04.6451612903225815.06.0.1.01.04Native American/American Indian12Hispanic/Latino45White/Caucasian1051Black/African American33Asian/Pacific Islander10UNF:6:rJ0RhYxBxKNTTdqBnDUn+Q==4.02.0.4.2661290322580651.16248172268343168.01.0124.05College Graduate (4 years)506Master's Degree72Highschool or Equivalent173Vocational/Technical School44Some College448Professional Degree (JD,MD,etc.)11Grammar School07Doctoral Degree (PhD)1UNF:6:a2DWjDkniqdzwf4wau6Y3Q==10.07.06.5124.0.1.60537714333975863.01.0UNF:6:VDo90XUHlK66Sb/bDjs4xg==0.0125.01.07.04.3333333333333334.458666666666667.1.2555710976930003UNF:6:wlcNjxUwSvsr7n/wmG3tQg==Subj0.0125.036.2284418654736125.063.0.63.01.0UNF:6:3b0qfJJ8xDPsYdC9dLqbPQ==Consent1.01.00.00.01.0.125.01.0UNF:6:1/+mJY4HXLkInuZm6rhTRw==Condition1.46400000000000040.0125.02.00.50070917449089561.01.0.UNF:6:VfUWB7jnvGKBhO4XjVLU5A==Blame.1.5960839172699365.0125.01.00.04.6639999999999997.0UNF:6:GJsxJ3biUP3gzDUhZMtH2A==Cause125.00.04.8721.59624559513879247.0.1.05.0UNF:6:Eh4FpE3i8d6YDdqA9oq7Cw==Made125.07.01.03.55200000000000054.0.0.01.6822412085878071UNF:6:F86SbhR2h3jRHuJe47UU4A==Because1.00.05.0125.07.04.952.1.3845693402876285UNF:6:zo8UghW+XCJbLq+BD57Y4g==Time35.651425324856326261.660.0.0.93647.94291240.343125.0UNF:6:s0v3ao7Wz8xJ9XtA4D4dyw==SummaryUNF:6:LDppOOutRAcos4Gil+wm9g==Age.124.071.018.031.0725806451612911.09689283919153628.01.0UNF:6:5i8+6W99U5IYU0Hr2IUi9w==Gender1.02.00.49722674863437332.0.1.43089430894308941.0123.0UNF:6:OrXD8C+/keI/UnabFdUBPg==Ethnicity124.00.94734158112842575.04.6451612903225811.0.6.01.0UNF:6:rJ0RhYxBxKNTTdqBnDUn+Q==Education1.04.266129032258065.1.16248172268343168.04.02.0124.0UNF:6:a2DWjDkniqdzwf4wau6Y3Q==SES1.6053771433397586.10.07.0124.06.51.03.0UNF:6:VDo90XUHlK66Sb/bDjs4xg==UNF:6:nnhLaAVw+c+hmHXLfb7dEA==1.00.0.1.01.00.01.0193.0UNF:6:fld9gK/e+xXoxAHUbdBLeA==.4.4696.919336787564767193.070.5660.00.08.280109855195665UNF:6:H3giQ0/UIG9SzsrGTocJjw==193.01.00.51295336787564770.5011321379527746.1.00.00.0UNF:6:3hFaXsObA0MfVuRXJzfu+A==193.00.01.04.02.54404145077720363.01.1177443051101699.UNF:6:emNeU/KsKoGljDcjm4t7aA==7.01.0193.00.04.953367875647668.1.85205447701671385.0UNF:6:OdlLlus+c5KOksjuB3uGPQ==1.02.110287635200832.193.07.04.03.76165803108808340.0UNF:6:2YO+y3eIDA54uZY/nvMu+A==1.01.7558961860642246193.07.0.6.00.05.227979274611399UNF:6:ZDnIt6eNJsnZnDeUohGA9Q==1.00.01.91057924193781185.04.782383419689119193.0.7.0UNF:6:mBTNykppqbsf+nsmGgDZzQ==2.03200588765415365.0193.0.0.07.04.668393782383421.0UNF:6:91kxY88XPh26AIbsZ8IpIQ==193.01.9781431996027767.0.0.06.05.4300518134715041.0UNF:6:DPceW5klrAgdnMocvUpGzA==7.05.0193.0.0.04.5906735751295321.02.312402264190535UNF:6:r79fAOMY2voMiFAgEAQhNQ==.804.6830.057.9953316062176163.63012273666628193.045.7780.0UNF:6:NlWGeJPMwsgMwJRS3tyXXQ==0.022.649114.888.193.025.8347512953367870.014.138621385319261UNF:6:IEkenLWETBKUcYRqGAqMmQ==UNF:6:P7DD+BXU+JlPgj3CUCc2WA==10.1455162940384851.028.0192.018.073.0.30.770833333333336UNF:6:UFkYnJy+LuMLpGfZGoIfxw==4.01.01.01.3492063492063492.0.189.00.4779854720060382UNF:6:YufOrWpF6YkXPNv3pObSHw==3.01.2794130685809414.352631578947369.5.01.06.0190.0UNF:6:NOyIw4XNLsgQMZyPs4rhSg==UNF:6:9gPcf2M+lgJc2gnbbzs45g==1.08886108181777821.04.06.0.192.01.04.234375UNF:6:D9NrVIN6ZuyTIiNovDIGgQ==3.010.06.0.1.62179170466904641.0192.06.276041666666666UNF:6:A5GURSD87E/3RRgT6xyBQA==UNF:6:51ZKXgvd7w4947mgy5ugkw==UNF:6:bbZ+8nI02/THbWc4k43Qbg==4.5906735751295345.0193.00.0.1.07.01.6969418489862629UNF:6:ezN3tMPcq3nELGj7yqSDAg==4.896373056994819.5.3333333333333330.01.01.90839809907369047.0193.0UNF:6:n3Yu1b7FmVOOqEcufLYHCw==1.01.12050484544531263.0405.04.02.506172839506173.0.04Orange Riot1021Industrial Workers1013Mother in law1022Mining Collapse100UNF:6:/ArpPEiLxGfT8sSeftMP8w==0.50061690338083780.01.00.01.0.0.5012345679012338405.00Accident2021Manipulation203UNF:6:LeufSTsOUa8KWLub3CTFDw==5.01.0.1.8315172523196620.04.844444444444445405.07.0UNF:6:C31IA0jsEC7YXldxGkb7nQ==0.01.0.5.07.0405.02.10373036699920144.0864197530864175UNF:6:DIrs1P6GXW0Q1+Hl4oXOFQ==7.01.84525410675442460.0.7.0405.05.6543209876543181.0UNF:6:9rV4KppgR0zeNC7iR/ez4w==0.0405.00.99506172839506170.07018581167423783.1.00.01.0UNF:6:Q0tk5okVK6P81xy95UvAow==UNF:6:M1n5OURfeYt0m45Hx3E7Xg==75.0.10.40090919931068429.8482587064676518.0402.026.03.0UNF:6:faNnKbugrcg+ApHz2AT6Dg==.2.01.00.46674978478410741.319201995012469401.01.04.0UNF:6:x3zJdzbVaHmATSOsvFKnUw==.401.01.04.04.4039900249376565.06.01.2150654467559596UNF:6:j/IWP/Uw1OZClugYRbGOng==UNF:6:pMEi3DtoXbuFoV0ylrDm7A==4.3457711442786073.01.0996914223101082402.01.0.4.08.0UNF:6:mGADoCQIXs0NP0Ad+PbQwg==2.010.0.1.64104157666986126.04.06.097256857855362401.0UNF:6:pL6XsTQFdAboeNoX6VfL8Q==ConditionUNF:6:oena5st5+SkTxVkWlTBHxQ==UNF:6:v6r/GZSMkCd33jfUD5Kovg==1.0.0.01.00.93827160493827160.2409592531772228405.00.0UNF:6:OteiXBGvx1GqQAyo1NlkyA==5.9061.047181.3640.08.15265679012345711.597059535483098.405.0UNF:6:D3cUNhnlCVpVReODNYeBJQ==471.904.0.048.252.68850.9410212804469662.47019012345679405.0UNF:6:0ID/GCsN39cQ9iztVpZrKA==405.03.03718.45072459201255612.2024444444444460.0244.286.9.277UNF:6:3fvpiUxJ62vT+YZ6n3hzww==0.0405.03.0995638441228893E-350.310759429856063360.43888815057819.1.04.836145488861912E-5UNF:6:Wcc3oYShVyg8zprGZLD9LA==405.01.2362140900045763E-211.00.9921722274703139.0.01.00.08622941232050903UNF:6:WTr06ypP6ebqyNETcZ28cQ==3.4250623486456833E-191.00.00.9744771565416771405.00.45917937255750424.0.5969497822694813UNF:6:ZIbC3RECq/Wbx/ToK8oYMQ==.0.66666593692335670.63329381319861930.0405.01.00.244697537725795445.767999397774875E-7UNF:6:bxOUnTaAk1lXyHLc+Jbp7w==Attn_Control=1 &time_control=1 (FILTER)0.249752352589045771.00.9333333333333331.0.00.0405.01.01Selected3780Not Selected27UNF:6:Z8Kbu0fA0Ys1IRc1YPBM0w==Consent405.0.1.00.01.00.01.01.0UNF:6:0AGBOZjs+95dreqYOMxxFA==Scenario4.03.0.1.00.01.1205048454453117405.02.5061728395061693UNF:6:HFGeIZjlEiaB5JwsVYboDw==Condition0.50123456790123460.00.0405.01.0.1.00.5006169033808353UNF:6:1l9JzA85oLcK16d2odYWlQ==Blame5.0405.01.04.844444444444445.0.01.83151725231966267.0UNF:6:YbxpZsg+epjOGDU5qw2IMg==Made.0.05.01.02.1037303669992037.04.08641975308642405.0UNF:6:zZjix+h5gNKP53dFYc+U4w==Wrong5.65432098765431951.8452541067544248405.07.01.0.7.00.0UNF:6:RYRYJGQWSeRBRyQu39CC2Q==Attn_Control0.070185811674238060.01.0405.00.0.0.99506172839506171.0UNF:6:+xmZnc1zLm9WChClQ/Fmhw==AttnCheckUNF:6:Huk/2lRrLQnsqC1oEDWZ2w==Age10.40090919931068218.075.0.402.029.84825870646765726.03.0UNF:6:H4fxft6CdDEvWCTYEWS8Zw==Gender.4.01.3192019950124692.01.01.0401.00.4667497847841072UNF:6:BaMuxkKp6EYoXKKgEM53bg==Ethnicity4.403990024937656401.01.21506544675596031.0.4.05.06.0UNF:6:AyDpLOOVl4nPHvImfAItqQ==Ethnicity_TEXTUNF:6:Yy8+DNN2hL0KhzsT6bwqhw==Education1.09969142231010898.04.0.1.0402.03.04.345771144278607UNF:6:pW58DJrcsrntZp+lXbB/1A==SES.6.0972568578553622.0401.04.06.01.641041576669860710.0UNF:6:9Bg7FWT6Le4iLW9JYNGo2A==Condition_textUNF:6:RyEu15iI1dPkpSDxCNMwig==OrderUNF:6:vvmtniDqiS6V93796F+X7A==Instr_Time181.3645.906.8.1526567901234571.0470.0405.011.597059535483085UNF:6:moIBrSv5yziQus9QzFz8ig==Vign_Time0.0.48.252.688471.90462.4701901234567950.941021280446954405.0UNF:6:+IlIdpJnFp/lbp4bdsyqjw==Med_Time12.2024444444444440.0244.28618.4507245920125639.2773.037405.0.UNF:6:Nf4JHlOLKW3ySF8JPNDCaQ==UNF:6:j5lyKM095o9Jo0dD4x/9lg==UNF:6:OD9O9CjAqaF1KgmYpUbkKw==UNF:6:Amljuw8TfG15l5tptwtdug==0.01.01.0300.0.0.01.01.0UNF:6:5sHYV+ZIm3iVhprqmhqtRA==UNF:6:vg6aMOHAc/2FRteXRZUEjw==4.0960.09299.06.968909698996655.1.013.74196152247222185.139UNF:6:hDnqViBnthv5id7M0cw30g==.300.00.00.00.50079090178762930.493333333333333230.01.02Intentional01Accidental148UNF:6:qgNycwiaIWREhz/WP9lKvA==.0.03.02.5100000000000014.01.0300.01.1287812707476322Mining Collapse693Industrial Workers784Orange Riot761Mother in law77UNF:6:cOGjqGoHig+Re0hIYeshxQ==0.50079090178762970.0300.01.00.01.0.0.5066666666666667UNF:6:qb6uO7GLAaOoFY0P5PSS1g==1.3520.044.98464634885186300.043.057353.558.55.58115UNF:6:VJTDqaUhyJ6jfspP6ITh+Q==.300.04.6799999999999985.01.90166271200602320.07.01.0UNF:6:C/Qzm7hucZa1i1haQOLGfw==1.0300.01.8394415322324556.00.07.05.12.UNF:6:JgO8SqGw7PVseBlWlzjyTA==.129.5496.0119.3577133333333330.012.0444334779114881.203300.0UNF:6:BWZN7St4pkNcm+Vd5HbAiA==UNF:6:ZSya/8FdMeuUCFd19+QQ4A==8.89603104560379229.6321070234113718.01.0.299.027.072.0UNF:6:pns1j+HRoHmR8sQIuXccKA==1.33670033670033673.0297.02.00.47337904905870454.1.01.01Male1972Female100UNF:6:NH6ZE1N1Z6nXJ1OSUWhp/g==2.0.5.06.01.17812775002015414.412751677852349298.01.05White/Caucasian2304Native American/American Indian33Asian/Pacific Islander341Black/African American152Hispanic/Latino15UNF:6:tMDP/5xUNFSXkVM5XjaFMw==NaNNaN.NaN0.0300.0NaNNaNUNF:6:+oB8lX6v40uFDLRToJbfLg==4.01.01.20020162462580988.04.2876254180602.299.01.01Grammer School15College Graduate (4 years)1232Highschool or Equivalent416Master's Degree198Professional Degree (JD,MD,etc.)49Other04Some College1013Vocational/Technical School97Doctoral Degree (PhD)1UNF:6:Cz1OnHQVtRTKodR+NfYeKQ==1.71579019822899382.06.3154362416107382.06.0298.010.0.UNF:6:5QCduqzDLTf+nk6NhzZ1bw==UNF:6:NQ8GnqJiIj65tD6D1H6+4w==UNF:6:3p5nxWf0P/eY6lHBlY8WsA==IPAddressUNF:6:j5lyKM095o9Jo0dD4x/9lg==startDateUNF:6:OD9O9CjAqaF1KgmYpUbkKw==endDateUNF:6:Amljuw8TfG15l5tptwtdug==Consent1.00.01.01.00.0300.0.1.0UNF:6:5sHYV+ZIm3iVhprqmhqtRA==MturkIDUNF:6:vg6aMOHAc/2FRteXRZUEjw==instrTime.299.00.0913.74196152247222185.1391.06.9689096989966554.096UNF:6:hDnqViBnthv5id7M0cw30g==Condition300.0.1.00.00.00.50079090178762930.493333333333333230.0UNF:6:qgNycwiaIWREhz/WP9lKvA==Scenario.3.01.0300.02.5100000000000014.01.1287812707476320.0UNF:6:cOGjqGoHig+Re0hIYeshxQ==causeQuestion0.50079090178762971.0300.00.0.1.00.50666666666666670.0UNF:6:qb6uO7GLAaOoFY0P5PSS1g==time353.558.1.35244.984646348851860.043.057300.055.58115UNF:6:VJTDqaUhyJ6jfspP6ITh+Q==Blame7.00.01.90166271200602321.0.4.679999999999998300.05.0UNF:6:C/Qzm7hucZa1i1haQOLGfw==Cause0.0300.06.05.12.7.01.8394415322324551.0UNF:6:JgO8SqGw7PVseBlWlzjyTA==mediateTime9.3577133333333336.011.129.5490.0300.012.0444334779114881.203UNF:6:BWZN7St4pkNcm+Vd5HbAiA==AttnCheckUNF:6:9ScHYhX/C+mgJdHYSpySXA==Age299.018.072.08.8960310456037921.029.63210702341137.27.0UNF:6:pns1j+HRoHmR8sQIuXccKA==Gender0.473379049058704541.03.02.0.1.01.3367003367003367297.0UNF:6:NH6ZE1N1Z6nXJ1OSUWhp/g==Ethnicity2.05.0.1.17812775002015416.01.0298.04.412751677852349UNF:6:tMDP/5xUNFSXkVM5XjaFMw==Ethnicity_TEXTUNF:6:uNPyftYDZ/EYu6StSBjbRw==Education4.08.04.28762541806021.0299.01.0.1.2002016246258098UNF:6:Cz1OnHQVtRTKodR+NfYeKQ==SES298.01.71579019822899386.3154362416107386.010.02.0.2.0UNF:6:5QCduqzDLTf+nk6NhzZ1bw==conditionTextUNF:6:NQ8GnqJiIj65tD6D1H6+4w==questionTextUNF:6:3p5nxWf0P/eY6lHBlY8WsA==Figures.pptxapplication/vnd.openxmlformats-officedocument.presentationml.presentationFigure_1.pngimage/pngFigure_2.pngimage/pngFigure_3.pngimage/pngFigure_4.pngimage/pngFigure_5.pngimage/pngFigure_6.pngimage/pngFigure_7.pngimage/pngFigure_8.pngimage/pngFigure_9.jpgimage/jpegFigure_9.pngimage/pngmanipulationAnalyses.Rtype/x-r-syntaxmanipulationSource.Rtype/x-r-syntaxREADME.mdtext/markdownStudy1_graph.pngimage/pngStudy1_graph.tiffimage/tiffStudy2_graph.pngimage/pngStudy2_graph.tiffimage/tiffStudy3_graph.pngimage/pngStudy3_graph.tiffimage/tiffStudy3_mediation.pngimage/pngStudy3_mediation.tifimage/tiffStudy4a_data.csvtext/csvStudy4a_graph.pngimage/pngStudy4a_graph.tiffimage/tiffStudy4a_mediation.pngimage/pngStudy4a_mediation.tifimage/tiffStudy4b_graph.pngimage/pngStudy4b_graph.tiffimage/tiffStudy4b_mediation.pngimage/pngStudy4b_mediation.tifimage/tiffStudy5_graph.pngimage/pngStudy5_graph.tiffimage/tiffStudy_1.qsfapplication/octet-streamStudy_2.qsfapplication/octet-streamStudy_3.qsfapplication/octet-streamStudy_4a.qsfapplication/octet-streamStudy_4b.qsfapplication/octet-streamStudy_5.qsfapplication/octet-streamThumbs-1.dbapplication/octet-streamThumbs-2.dbapplication/octet-streamThumbs-3.dbapplication/octet-streamThumbs-4.dbapplication/octet-streamThumbs-5.dbapplication/octet-streamThumbs.dbapplication/octet-stream