Vol. 17(1): Replication Data for: Who Participates in Local Government? Evidence from Meeting Minutesdoi:10.7910/DVN/RRF7EUHarvard Dataverse2019-02-151Einstein, Katherine Levine; Palmer, Maxwell; Glick, David M., 2019, "Vol. 17(1): Replication Data for: Who Participates in Local Government? Evidence from Meeting Minutes", https://doi.org/10.7910/DVN/RRF7EU, Harvard Dataverse, V1, UNF:6:LGBnP5waVqr9O9j527Ksgw== [fileUNF]Vol. 17(1): Replication Data for: Who Participates in Local Government? Evidence from Meeting Minutesdoi:10.7910/DVN/RRF7EUEinstein, Katherine LevinePalmer, MaxwellGlick, David M.Harvard DataversePalmer, MaxwellPalmer, Maxwell2018-06-27Social SciencesScholars and policymakers have highlighted institutions that enable community participation as a potential buffer against existing political inequalities. Yet, these venues may be biasing policy discussions in favor of an unrepresentative group of individuals. To explore who participates, we compile a novel data set by coding thousands of instances of citizens speaking at planning and zoning board meetings concerning housing development. We match individuals to a voter file to investigate local political participation in housing and development policy. We find that individuals who are older, male, longtime residents, voters in local elections, and homeowners are significantly more likely to participate in these meetings. These individuals overwhelmingly (and to a much greater degree than the general public) oppose new housing construction. These participatory inequalities have important policy implications and may be contributing to rising housing costs.<a href="http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0">CC0 1.0</a>all_comments_anon.tab426813text/tab-separated-valuesUNF:6:GXRWovE/EnkKZwcl+h8r7A==comments_merged_anon.tab364420text/tab-separated-valuesUNF:6:t/oA0NLqJAvfkhM4dGTPtg==reasons_by_comment.tab55815text/tab-separated-valuesUNF:6:djrvYYL9Ixr6QEV2bNfcNg==reasons_codes.tab202text/tab-separated-valuesUNF:6:v/JbP67DON3/GsHknFIvOw==town_40b_support_comments.tab9713text/tab-separated-valuesUNF:6:vXF2ybanmZHuxe90Y/hSDg==1679.50.04268.03327.01.01646.768978444277960.186022644187.UNF:6:RCgnZ6ktLPWemlBhIEkFFQ==0.0.1232.20980356431194268.01.02134.52134.54268.0UNF:6:iFcfzw9WT4tFbOim2oIA9A==TownUNF:6:Kw/sOokIQ/7lKurXeZpfzw==Planning Board/Zoning BoardUNF:6:QrWYpWLAncdJ5bBwLa9zSQ==Project UNF:6:UKFRlUR7/MRgUXW+9ri56w==PositionUNF:6:Of+VHNdz7vs01R2dppQEHw==ReasonsUNF:6:WHolYCACLOb7avNeGxpQ+A==Reasons_CodeUNF:6:wSIR1oX/FUKWSVDPoDkgBQ==UNF:6:F/NMeZUCBAdXpFjYC1xfxA==.0.352646968596322554268.00.00.01.00.145501405810683710.0UNF:6:fJvJR5BHWo+TSDm7mEdMLA==.4268.00.01.00.62558575445173370.48402800665759290.01.0UNF:6:8vFU2LLAvg+zRFybtpQ5Lw==0.00.4194239318373425.0.227741330834114660.01.00.04268.0UNF:6:kEVskssehN7AX6x6cfkUiw==5.0.0.73559263898102131.0-0.4806474313863484-1.0-1.04263.0UNF:6:r8CAY1bG3UD2IdNQ/jpPIA==1660.01624.96789242593630.03644.03326.01.0953.8170310374345.UNF:6:8GyZCNfbqQ5HdJHx2E1dgw==2108.25054884739531.02098.54268.01229.61813713675060.03644.0.UNF:6:l2k9FybrnuIpdJ1k2Oa+8A==TownUNF:6:J+N1JWgPZcTbPgBXSkNImA==Planning Board/Zoning BoardUNF:6:9huGVvxolvrwXeYd57r54A==Project UNF:6:0/HxPK8UtagTOf9gY7n9tA==PositionUNF:6:6z2ZRRDwKRzIDvajKX+ZDA==0.0.0.144072447859495080.00.03644.00.35121137173338881.0UNF:6:h7bU66U3krOnrv1hMbebvQ==0.62403951701427031.00.0.3644.00.484436373108870061.00.0UNF:6:VMzXfdOxcCTCHZW2dxiXJw==0.03644.0.0.00.421220867196198670.230515916575191520.01.0UNF:6:m3o8DLxf1H5upav83ML7CA==5.00.7336984435877184-1.03639.0-0.48062654575432811.0-1.0.UNF:6:qlpWlueEhSH1gT1jehYbpg==Age58.8121650950184319.37577056884765612.5139765275091383629.015.0.94.8364105224609458.959617614746094UNF:6:DDqqDDkQVefpIqIEjxGD4w==Reg. Length17.5729042397552570.271047234535217310.7018780905410630.03644.0.117.4127273559570319.492128372192383UNF:6:gVAK/A00M/k1D/N/1OdTug==% Elections Voted0.33408290695679291.00.5167436010319777.3644.00.54545456171035770.00.0UNF:6:hyRpOtT/41zBQz1M4MlWNA==Reg. Democrat1.00.462031489007271760.00.308726673984632660.00.03644.0.UNF:6:8S0Kb4Uuhqz+1Dl4h52X0A==Reg. Republican0.01.00.120472008781558963644.00.00.0.0.3255573519200789UNF:6:iCyNhO8RsL9btv5YRm/4yw==3644.00.01.00.043792718019990180.00.001920965971459994.0.0UNF:6:MjCryr5Tc67piIKUfRY79Q==Female1.00.00.42535675082327083644.00.49446484274342134.0.00.0UNF:6:9zxOsW8IsvTrw1ECCajxQw==Reg. Independent0.49530073653116774.1.00.00.00.56888035126234783644.01.0UNF:6:9nsBoZot00aR91v5/+J5tg==Number of comments17.0.1.03644.01.01.8094034100700850.01.8913282107574023UNF:6:/uwLifKzBDC4zFwmqrnthQ==1.01.0.0.00.35259688330981560.03644.00.8545554335894626UNF:6:zlTwaNvW59AaCCC9r2klVg==1149.4681112687471.05581.04268.00.01970.4454398852852.1992.0UNF:6:pc4rhcIbNDbBhKhzthNmxQ==PositionUNF:6:At4qj6r/dZmi4UNBZ+UQzg==1.0-1.00.6350915505608374.0.05581.0-0.6876903780684427-1.0UNF:6:3EkNNn1XaTG5+InkWGaObA==0.010.197276473750231.012.05.7092925354118985581.020.0.UNF:6:8eHbZXk0DW/hoHL5k57jFQ==CodeUNF:6:AJ+iH/bHX18pnl4qYIsUow==20.010.5.10.55.9160797830996161.00.020.0UNF:6:/FIOZM/29oC3TK/IE52m2A==CodeUNF:6:pzLWEGHgLBCTfZp6dk5Zjg==TownUNF:6:6Ljnin3hXQijOklphqZY5g==(count) comment_id.0.097.037.5670103092783542.83906589796642251.021.01.0UNF:6:kGFlSnsxi7KJ5lqx6995NQ==(sum) support2.0.12.73999000630788397.00.00.05.4123711340206293.0UNF:6:LbG87dfNG3IBovaJq6kTOg==(sum) oppose14.00.0127.023.44329896907216726.026416496899884.0.097.0UNF:6:Ew+W8Hluk11qZHxQtoQywQ==(sum) neutral97.00.09.98528771695528.8.6597938144329916.050.00.0UNF:6:CNwEWlM9p47pdUSSOb3XdQ==(sum) n_or_o32.10309278350515433.449428413178964.19.00.0158.00.097.0UNF:6:N2l8eeZiQM3aZvvb61+x3A==0.097.0.1.00.00.119482439280170740.166544434615752940.05882352963089943UNF:6:lEcIvzfpxWoNfV/ZGF0rwA==(sum) n.23.048.46325927958210.097.044.0280.01.0UNF:6:zdjElKdELHKzPP5yxWMM/w==CountyUNF:6:MX8aVD+9xIj8exI/j/cvdg==UNF:6:1dsJVpSuK517QKQ08WR/Vg==1.02428.85757635274653936.32291666666713829.096.0744.03131.5.UNF:6:Bm8rOlvPzA76CPmG7Uvm8A==4576.61703141009725171.04957.645833333334953.096.0.1.03567.0UNF:6:gcNR+YJ8CiTwAHzBl8++MA==0.5275856281320254.0.79527837038040160.07765819831115710.37330549955368041.096.00.5181461572647095UNF:6:RJPj9IigFbdTuo3rY7zzZA==readme.txttext/plainzoning_participation_graphs.Rtype/x-r-syntaxzoning_participation_main_analysis.doapplication/x-stata-syntax