Replication Data for: Fighting Organized Crime by Targeting their Revenue: Screening, Mafias and Public Fundsdoi:10.7910/DVN/R1IIXHHarvard Dataverse2022-03-121Dipoppa, Gemma; Daniele, Gianmarco, 2022, "Replication Data for: Fighting Organized Crime by Targeting their Revenue: Screening, Mafias and Public Funds", https://doi.org/10.7910/DVN/R1IIXH, Harvard Dataverse, V1, UNF:6:RdpJ9q1ZrWcXvFQCwdHLlg== [fileUNF]Replication Data for: Fighting Organized Crime by Targeting their Revenue: Screening, Mafias and Public Fundsdoi:10.7910/DVN/R1IIXHDipoppa, GemmaDaniele, GianmarcoHarvard DataverseDipoppa, GemmaDaniele, GianmarcoDipoppa, Gemma2022-03-12Social Sciencesorganized crime, public funds misappropriation, european fundsRepressive policies to fight criminal organizations are often met with a violent response from criminal groups. Are non-repressive strategies more effective? Targeting criminal revenues can be a powerful tool if the threat of investigation is credible and if criminals are unable to displace their activity to avoid controls. We study an Italian policy designed to tackle mafia misappropriation of public funds by screening companies applying for subsidies over 150,000 Euros. Using all subsidies to firms co-financed by the European Union from 2008 to 2015, we find that a group of firms starts self-selecting below the threshold immediately after its introduction. Those firms are concentrated in mafia-affected cities, are lower performing, operate in typical mafia sectors and have balance sheet indicators of money laundering. While avoiding violence, non-repressive strategies might have different unintended consequences: criminal organizations react with an immediate strategic displacement which reduces states' capacity to detect them, highlighting the importance of designing policies that anticipate the sophistication of criminal organizations.<a href="http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0">CC0 1.0</a>Daniele, Gianmarco and Dipoppa, Gemma (2022) Fighting Organized Crime by Targeting their Revenue: Screening, Mafias and Public Funds. The Journal of Law, Economics, and Organization.Daniele, Gianmarco and Dipoppa, Gemma (2022) Fighting Organized Crime by Targeting their Revenue: Screening, Mafias and Public Funds. The Journal of Law, Economics, and Organization.city-coord.tab8708913text/tab-separated-valuesUNF:6:QdIwzb16z4hCumT8XHaNWw==data_agea.tab945772text/tab-separated-valuesUNF:6:dC08rx+OzytA7vuGrZZM1g==data_below50000.tab996927text/tab-separated-valuesUNF:6:YnfKFYFuBItx7lpw9ZVruQ==data_figureheads.tab220389text/tab-separated-valuesUNF:6:yZdP0kCj1LtBMyUfqTLKxw==data_funds.tab907833text/tab-separated-valuesUNF:6:tTbYzuc/f5iImzgf0EXi5Q==data_opencoesione.tab2113610text/tab-separated-valuesUNF:6:+rcNxvSESaPNeBf1VvDIOw==data_placebo_opencoesione.tab15844text/tab-separated-valuesUNF:6:L4SByXo2zL20Gvtu+J3vYw==data_placebo.tab15444text/tab-separated-valuesUNF:6:yxu3dpEBPBXbSjsmzz2Zxg==4641.04426.136516545801870891.0.1.00.02292.92760377436758092.0UNF:6:RFQiec4m/lW/P+v/eeMHdw==237011.33553409265313279.25139203377861817.0.719182.20035070941312016.150673101743609.25434914519074.0UNF:6:Zh/BlokKdn0qrUNHlbQT7w==861817.04837922.9853054874765540.1872331735220292.29226027153933846.2156490004290159.9492713397.9074.0UNF:6:S5DIk1l8VlKi6tB0UeFSqg==94344.5018262654850602.29898073403575027.0937594577.050000.00.0300000.0.UNF:6:yxnullqvq+VA/8jN/Qhhnw==2011.87851386097782012.02.89351590092917152027.0.2015.092562.02001.0UNF:6:pa4VpuNGxQ3HeoDmUakDpw==COD_REGIONE55.014.0701.09.3156605019621250.012.71357026004376.99637.0UNF:6:3UooSXktr5bHeIlX9RYy/A==COD_COMUNE42.5078133625021350.5296082514117499637.00.027.0315.055.0.UNF:6:0zH/Hrt63xynzaqO1D+LAw==FINANZ_TOTALE_PUBBLICO44582.25319486177699692.0.250000.00.04000.0136022.1290094475917170.0UNF:6:9qtG9aRd1gRLqOJJA2NKug==0.099692.00.00.180505958351737050.00.38461024579642805.1.0UNF:6:xD/hnYXVPpU1Slwog/bQsg==Year.2015.00.02008.02011.37434297636722011.02.05195014261009599692.0UNF:6:jzvQInXt3yDHZixqlZ8Xvg==0.099692.01.0.1.00.01.01.0UNF:6:b5pUieG+3hQ43gLqV4B5LQ==18000.0.5000.044610.010552261454250000.00.036382.5482486025399692.0UNF:6:9Yhb8B2YMkGp/ySLtWxukw==COD_COMUNE315.0.86.7172455303260528.020182.071.34392032503971856.00.0UNF:6:fct0Wihnqzd/G+GgBs4Wlw==.2011.23595282925382011.01856.02015.02007.020182.02.0723066412276925UNF:6:o1b/943r7+x8DtMuLLNx7Q==DESCR_FORMA_GIURIDICA_SOGG8.1288882017382862.020182.050.161480527202631856.0.57.054.048Societ���� cooperativa sociale69914Citt���� metropolitana050Societ���� di mutuo soccorso256Societ���� a responsabilit���� limitata45423Ente o autorit���� portuale046Societ���� cooperativa a mutualit���� prevalente12111Azienda pubblica di servizi alle persone ai sensi del d.lgs n. 207/2001035Istituto pubblico di assistenza e beneficenza05Archivio notarile038Ministero015Comitato024Ente parco052Societ���� in accomandita semplice6721Ente di sviluppo agricolo regionale o di altro ente locale017Comunit���� montana o isolana027Ente pubblico economico025Ente per il turismo019Consorzio di diritto pubblico2242Privato969Autorit���� indipendenti518Consorzio di diritto privato28549Societ���� di fatto o irregolare, comunione ereditaria737222Ente ecclesiastico020Ente ambientale regionale029Fondazione bancaria04Altro ente pubblico non economico nazionale31234Istituto o ente pubblico di ricerca037Libero professionista243Provincia08Associazione riconosciuta644Regione059Universit���� pubblica033Istituto e scuola pubblica di ogni ordine e grado01Agenzia dello Stato06Associazione non riconosciuta339Ordine e collegio professionale053Societ���� in nome collettivo12040Organo costituzionale o a rilevanza costituzionale058Unione di comuni045Societ���� consortile1727Associazione o raggruppamento temporaneo di imprese230Imprenditore individuale agricolo028Fondazione (esclusa fondazione bancaria)036Lavoratore autonomo1010Azienda o ente del servizio sanitario nazionale1913Camera di commercio016Comune031Imprenditore individuale non agricolo1641Presidenza del consiglio03Altra forma di ente privato senza personalit���� giuridica612Azienda speciale ai sensi del t.u. 267/20004054Societ���� per azioni1001155Societ���� semplice1047Societ���� cooperativa diversa31326Ente per la ricerca e per l'aggiornamento educativo032Impresa o ente privato costituito all'estero non altrimenti classificabile che svolge una attivit���� economica in Italia257Studio associato e societ���� di professionisti72Altra forma di ente privato con personalit���� giuridica851Societ���� in accomandita per azioni0UNF:6:zleNcvFqnnxnQg1NqHB3sw==1856.0.1.00.00.00.19254781488454630.3943106108194735520182.00Before 2014 Law162961After 2014 Law3886UNF:6:T+mYm2JI7V0OuEgoC+LBuA==0.4732516579429233420182.01856.00.0.1.01.00.661381428996128UNF:6:HJIoUcvC5XtQowg0Um4cRQ==BoD concentration1856.00.00256410264410078530.366237004376106.20182.00.326405537809519030.28571429848670961.0UNF:6:4AlVaXbe7NCyK1vHFi60Dw==0.00.268084952031242941856.00.00.077940739272623571.0.20182.0UNF:6:j9s2N5co3iqh6G1yRPFkiw==BoD 64+ old1856.00.206471112872853390.01.0.20182.00.00.40478254778148215UNF:6:drVK6omnQyxw62emLtA3Zg==1.00.00.461923672248567341856.0.0.020182.00.3085918144881461UNF:6:Cxtxqcpueu1owwOdsHjE4w==UNF:6:3h1rVBtfj2uytLGuL89N5Q==Govt Inefficiency0.4490322544507274.0.00.71998237497246161.09078.01.00.0UNF:6:zkuh5TCKbiDo8hIayr/9BQ==Corruption0.09078.0.1.00.456462527197628250.70411985018725920.01.0UNF:6:nL7N90MzTdEZcCCP3HYIJw==COD_REGIONE.5.6183539688431419.5490196078434921.09.00.09078.020.0UNF:6:yDGEj3YD8sF8czT11F/2/w==COD_COMUNE0.09078.060.7007050011015333.070.02087053757205315.0.1.0UNF:6:xmUCDihDjlo0TqWR9BCTYQ==Amount of subsidies9078.0250000.050000.0.0.0114885.0840493501952292.078208707586100000.0UNF:6:oYjXZ562SAwdQmXFLr2LFg==2015.02011.02011.33421458471039078.00.02008.0.2.0460166387766394UNF:6:vcNQMPFS025p5+VHDHiJbQ==DESCR_FORMA_GIURIDICA_SOGG9078.00.054.09.12088139156312450.1619299405154857.0.2.038Ministero03Altra forma di ente privato senza personalit���� giuridica236Lavoratore autonomo620Ente ambientale regionale040Organo costituzionale o a rilevanza costituzionale057Studio associato e societ���� di professionisti126Ente per la ricerca e per l'aggiornamento educativo032Impresa o ente privato costituito all'estero non altrimenti classificabile che svolge una attivit���� economica in Italia153Societ���� in nome collettivo7322Ente ecclesiastico145Societ���� consortile10411Azienda pubblica di servizi alle persone ai sensi del d.lgs n. 207/2001041Presidenza del consiglio047Societ���� cooperativa diversa16742Privato4339Ordine e collegio professionale034Istituto o ente pubblico di ricerca035Istituto pubblico di assistenza e beneficenza023Ente o autorit���� portuale08Associazione riconosciuta1617Comunit���� montana o isolana048Societ���� cooperativa sociale29915Comitato07Associazione o raggruppamento temporaneo di imprese527Ente pubblico economico010Azienda o ente del servizio sanitario nazionale1655Societ���� semplice512Azienda speciale ai sensi del t.u. 267/20001125Ente per il turismo031Imprenditore individuale non agricolo126Associazione non riconosciuta129Fondazione bancaria02Altra forma di ente privato con personalit���� giuridica105Archivio notarile013Camera di commercio019Consorzio di diritto pubblico843Provincia09Autorit���� indipendenti556Societ���� a responsabilit���� limitata21218Consorzio di diritto privato16837Libero professionista144Regione01Agenzia dello Stato052Societ���� in accomandita semplice6146Societ���� cooperativa a mutualit���� prevalente8930Imprenditore individuale agricolo028Fondazione (esclusa fondazione bancaria)316Comune559Universit���� pubblica050Societ���� di mutuo soccorso149Societ���� di fatto o irregolare, comunione ereditaria236314Citt���� metropolitana033Istituto e scuola pubblica di ogni ordine e grado058Unione di comuni051Societ���� in accomandita per azioni024Ente parco054Societ���� per azioni522821Ente di sviluppo agricolo regionale o di altro ente locale04Altro ente pubblico non economico nazionale161UNF:6:6kN7IIZ0lA8GgzElDrDmlQ==0.38854845826592550.01.0.9078.00.00.00.185283102004842021After 2014 Law16820Before 2014 Law7396UNF:6:og0nAlfBr/tj+mUS8PuyCg==Private cofinancing0.09078.00.67481824190350670.46846852352102214.0.01.01.0UNF:6:36wDhgVX51h32HhtYgKfww==Mafia presence1.00.67580964970258710.00.46809732322171670.01.09078.0.UNF:6:05QTUIwITlFuf5h97yLIVA==Year9078.02011.33421458471032.04601663877663940.0.2008.02011.02015.0UNF:6:vcNQMPFS025p5+VHDHiJbQ==0.09078.01.01.00.01.01.0.UNF:6:041Pxuo4GZ+64ThnKXQodQ==Bin9078.0115288.7199823751752284.13262016803550000.0250000.0100000.00.0.UNF:6:djhyQzWwRyBAqEW8hubSSA==Just Below 150k, dummy0.0.0.00.00.124950489889143281.00.0158625247851948539078.0UNF:6:fOXykQ5sucjqrmV+/1M11w==0.01.00.466719456416575360.0451.00.31929046563192918627.0.UNF:6:tjIQABh/DhtAhAE5o5bWgQ==0.497176693164557540.00.01.09078.00.55331570830579951.0.UNF:6:Fwui3g4okb051kggqy3Prw==9078.0.0.44196158481390930.00.00.01.00.26613791584049556UNF:6:BRtMPDf+PoT4xgb2zofNug==Company Life14.013.4075903508522670.00.0.9078.017.079863406036242127.0UNF:6:ngTEitPQx6Jvxx//7UH7uw==Created 2y before call0.00.116655651024454170.32102719925268111.00.09078.0.0.0UNF:6:4GZSDvEu28JkOGbA4UzeDQ==Research, education9078.00.01.00.488668151970940050.00.394029521921133660.0.UNF:6:eF8Ilw5FesZweqennWKS1A==Construction, transport9078.00.0.0.01.00.00.28761841815377410.4526771880446886UNF:6:198hIHl8ksoHm4ofA2GSDQ==UNF:6:awr5GlieAH6rlfaJotU9ZQ==Total Cash35823.398437523.173055076642108-7.510375022888184.3198.0506.769195975400242.3769375085830695880.0UNF:6:0i6u1P+CHzwJWBV5eRBsqw==Cash Ratio0.8726898431777954.4.1981550748459995E-40.0288034800710323740.0060591590471626235880.03198.0-8.090625487966463E-5UNF:6:e4J9PXxVuWNkWVegfa6iRQ==Return on Assets.162.1979980468752.138751748209729-884.849975585937514.8642922708806592.60732150077819829020.058.0UNF:6:sbAQzd2yGQJnAgqohu/pPg==Total Debt, winsorized1055.08023.0.3320.954697161196211680.8652343751586.4427490234375162.05940246582033796.307793671522UNF:6:j7v39BeUvPkEy+hcobOIRw==Bank Debt, winsorized0.07825.01253.0602.2309815507501146.12780761718752743.21240234375.896.7167361657074UNF:6:etlBH0/cQeXtGqKtG7BnTw==UNF:6:g3yNrpMPRgY6wlo7Vh1/+Q==BoD from mafia area0.03264.00.01.00.41950464396284540.49352040489973375814.0.UNF:6:2f13j5gNl+TG8eVhLAzqww==Area ID.4485.04.02214.5225577810868089.09078.00.04000.5719321437477UNF:6:ezvI+jW4kBwrQVr9Pe/jog==x-coordinate of area centroid9078.0748627.5625345957.78125253643.29912640020.01306346.5743385.8296293401.UNF:6:QG18lPI2EuYnf7qoUwkcNg==y-coordinate of area centroid4825346.04778611.5240140865169710.59078.0.226098.166773439043944592.250.0UNF:6:kU/RR9xFtxuHcieJbzHCeg==COD_REGIONE.12.011.28277233347524513.00.08.352900679464485701.021123.0UNF:6:KqCxyNQQOsjCRkkpgUUD+g==COD_COMUNE315.013.061.8341414008962521123.032.00.0.52.18434881408987UNF:6:yTyIxQ1JgvvAC9tb/rzieA==FINANZ_TOTALE_PUBBLICO107808.87623012895250000.021136.049186.0920729468593750.0.50000.00.0UNF:6:yNAWEaG+D7KsmFid/a28xw==1.00.00.171177138531406430.021136.00.0.0.376672588064357550Before 2014 Law175181After 2014 Law3618UNF:6:q9bs8JgIQRVj506Ga9w93w==1.0.0.00.62845382286147040.483229410734365260.021136.01.0UNF:6:vnwdB3JUB6JhoEdANv3UoQ==Year2011.00.02008.02015.02.02020440106612982011.2960352006055.21136.0UNF:6:NywFFuHgRvuMgoRnCVUL5A==.1.021136.01.01.00.01.00.0UNF:6:fEdEZhJ/y8uozEOFMo6k4w==Bin49177.0086146635150000.0108225.4447388337721136.094000.00.0.250000.0UNF:6:g+hsH4Sj/QQtz1bWcVehgw==.0.12116956332200760.014903482210445620.00.021136.00.01.0UNF:6:IdCuLNyYou+2kFLbrFN6dg==0.49999204845796021.00.495552611657853640.0.0.021136.00.0UNF:6:7nT2Rbj62RHn+dMzj0sDmQ==Year2008.01584.02011.50.02.2920114501637242011.52015.0.UNF:6:VPsAhPolbWjEgH5F2kRhDA==Bin148500.00.050000.0247000.0.148500.057174.9981804099441584.0UNF:6:eoqr5gBSiyU04RayylzMOQ==(rawsum) n0.00.317195347065107160.02.0.0.089646464646465420.01584.0UNF:6:+mKB0v0iL3GgHHZcu1d7Gw==0.250.00.43314944994612330.01.00.01584.0.0Before 201311881After 2013396UNF:6:5oXHJwOF+wRIiMguMK+dNw==Bin.243000.0147000.01544.055731.603831098560.051000.0147000.0UNF:6:bCoRUVDV6vMG1IOWOJdM1A==0.0.2.2920302054586741544.02015.02011.52008.02011.5UNF:6:aTPgpf1X50682lSXGHkAlg==(rawsum) n.0.172076019581360180.00.02.00.029145077720207490.01544.0UNF:6:BUQqawDvdXnJSaeXqmTbPA==0.00.43315299436370930.01.00.0.0.251544.01After 20133860Before 20131158UNF:6:uVKWGrQZVj9oa7LUfqXtzw==analyses.doapplication/x-stata-syntaxbunch_count.adoapplication/x-stata-adobunch_count.pdfapplication/pdfbunch_count.sthlpapplication/octet-streamdata_generation_description.pdfapplication/pdffigure2.pdfapplication/pdffigure3.pdfapplication/pdffigure4.pdfapplication/pdffigure5_lower.pdfapplication/pdffigure5_upper.pdfapplication/pdffigureA1.pdfapplication/pdffigureA2.pdfapplication/pdffigureB3_left.pdfapplication/pdffigureB3_right.pdfapplication/pdffigureB4_center.pdfapplication/pdffigureB4_left.pdfapplication/pdffigureB4_right.pdfapplication/pdffigureB5_left.pdfapplication/pdffigureB5_right.pdfapplication/pdffigureB6.pdfapplication/pdffigureB7.pdfapplication/pdffigureB8.pdfapplication/pdffigureD9.pdfapplication/pdffigureE10.pdfapplication/pdffigureE11_left.pdfapplication/pdffigureE11_right.pdfapplication/pdffigureE12_left.pdfapplication/pdffigureE12_right.pdfapplication/pdffigureE13_left.pdfapplication/pdffigureE13_right.pdfapplication/pdffigureE14_left.pdfapplication/pdffigureE14_right.pdfapplication/pdffigureE15_left.pdfapplication/pdffigureE15_right.pdfapplication/pdfInstaller.doapplication/x-stata-syntaxReadMe.txttext/plainsimulation optimal threshold.xlsxapplication/vnd.openxmlformats-officedocument.spreadsheetml.sheettable1.pdfapplication/pdftable1.texapplication/x-textable1.txttext/plaintable2.pdfapplication/pdftable2.texapplication/x-textable2.txttext/plaintable3.pdfapplication/pdftable3.texapplication/x-textable3.txttext/plaintableA1.texapplication/x-textableA2.texapplication/x-textableA&.texapplication/x-textableF4.pdfapplication/pdftableF4.texapplication/x-textableF4.txttext/plaintableG5.pdfapplication/pdftableG5.texapplication/x-textableG5.txttext/plaintableG6.pdfapplication/pdftableG6.texapplication/x-textableG6.txttext/plain~$ta_generation_description.docxapplication/vnd.openxmlformats-officedocument.wordprocessingml.document