Replication Data for: 'Race to the Bottom: Competition and Quality in Science'doi:10.7910/DVN/KD7A8BHarvard Dataverse2025-01-232Hill, Ryan; Stein, Carolyn, 2025, "Replication Data for: 'Race to the Bottom: Competition and Quality in Science'", https://doi.org/10.7910/DVN/KD7A8B, Harvard Dataverse, V2, UNF:6:NiV5uyFxWELxKJbH7j7h5w== [fileUNF]Replication Data for: 'Race to the Bottom: Competition and Quality in Science'doi:10.7910/DVN/KD7A8BHill, RyanStein, CarolynHarvard DataverseStein, CarolynBaranga, Thomas2025-01-23Social SciencesAsymmetric and Private Information; Mechanism DesignAnalysis of Health Care MarketsHigher Education; Research InstitutionsInnovation and Invention: Processes and IncentivesOpen InnovationThe data and programs replicate tables and figures from "Race to the Bottom: Competition and Quality in Science," by Hill and Stein. Please see the README file for additional details.<a href="http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0">CC0 1.0</a>Hill, Ryan, and Carolyn Stein, "Race to the Bottom: Competition and Quality in Science," Quarterly Journal of Economics, vol. 140 no.2, May 2025, pp. 1111-1185.Hill, Ryan, and Carolyn Stein, "Race to the Bottom: Competition and Quality in Science," Quarterly Journal of Economics, vol. 140 no.2, May 2025, pp. 1111-1185.db_drug_index.tab1135517text/tab-separated-valuesUNF:6:jGp+KjY8ltxkG1QnhF0Kzw==db_target_all.tab512013text/tab-separated-valuesUNF:6:VJzzodUucm+AWCKb6LqpqA==db_target_pharmacologically_active.tab125613text/tab-separated-valuesUNF:6:iFxBY6BeSg1agqMpPlJ+4A==pdb_Citation.tab14558611text/tab-separated-valuesUNF:6:klhqzfzZpB+jNb62Bga7qg==pdb_ClusterEntity.tab42980714text/tab-separated-valuesUNF:6:nMSUPTeAmJRNK0PSpWtr8w==pdb_DataCollectionDetails.tab1370675text/tab-separated-valuesUNF:6:k1djg+Ea6Li8n+H0Ll9RIQ==pdb_RefinementDetails.tab1318367text/tab-separated-valuesUNF:6:tLgOOBp8+mwRlUi3/RcBJg==pdb_RefinementParameters.tab1321314text/tab-separated-valuesUNF:6:qyjh4HspX1I+H8rV4YYVtQ==pdb_Sequence.tab4907179text/tab-separated-valuesUNF:6:2BlzdVnrtseUU8459XdsVg==pdb_StructureSummary.tab14417315text/tab-separated-valuesUNF:6:LbvKE2F9w3kIA1rKtEaIEQ==phat.tab204343text/tab-separated-valuesUNF:6:MzvZM/pj52KAuuPMeFzNOw==scooped_groups.tab104106text/tab-separated-valuesUNF:6:7ZGzMJ8oWA4bFvYJFdDeNg==survey_data_050623.tab1056431text/tab-separated-valuesUNF:6:Zc+9Dd7iS1rrnVfIVjpV9w==wos_pubmed2pubmed.tab6040169text/tab-separated-valuesUNF:6:xRsi/Hljcx8dsJ/TG3gy0Q==DrugBank IDNaNNaN.0.0NaNNaN11355.0NaNUNF:6:tgzvlz9Pw9c8tGf4dIT6ZA==NameNaN.0.011355.0NaNNaNNaNNaNUNF:6:tgzvlz9Pw9c8tGf4dIT6ZA==CAS NumberNaN11355.0NaNNaN0.0NaNNaN.UNF:6:tgzvlz9Pw9c8tGf4dIT6ZA==Drug Groups.0.0NaNNaNNaNNaNNaN11355.0UNF:6:tgzvlz9Pw9c8tGf4dIT6ZA==InChIKeyNaNNaN11355.00.0NaNNaNNaN.UNF:6:tgzvlz9Pw9c8tGf4dIT6ZA==InChINaN0.0NaNNaN.11355.0NaNNaNUNF:6:tgzvlz9Pw9c8tGf4dIT6ZA==SMILES.NaNNaNNaNNaN0.011355.0NaNUNF:6:tgzvlz9Pw9c8tGf4dIT6ZA==FormulaNaNNaN11355.0NaNNaN0.0NaN.UNF:6:tgzvlz9Pw9c8tGf4dIT6ZA==KEGG Compound IDNaN11355.0NaNNaNNaN0.0.NaNUNF:6:tgzvlz9Pw9c8tGf4dIT6ZA==KEGG Drug IDNaN0.0NaNNaNNaNNaN.11355.0UNF:6:tgzvlz9Pw9c8tGf4dIT6ZA==PubChem Compound ID.NaNNaNNaN11355.0NaNNaN0.0UNF:6:tgzvlz9Pw9c8tGf4dIT6ZA==PubChem Substance IDNaN11355.0NaNNaNNaNNaN0.0.UNF:6:tgzvlz9Pw9c8tGf4dIT6ZA==ChEBI IDNaN.11355.00.0NaNNaNNaNNaNUNF:6:tgzvlz9Pw9c8tGf4dIT6ZA==ChEMBL ID.0.0NaN11355.0NaNNaNNaNNaNUNF:6:tgzvlz9Pw9c8tGf4dIT6ZA==HET IDNaN0.0NaN.NaNNaNNaN11355.0UNF:6:tgzvlz9Pw9c8tGf4dIT6ZA==ChemSpider IDNaNNaN11355.0NaN0.0.NaNNaNUNF:6:tgzvlz9Pw9c8tGf4dIT6ZA==BindingDB ID0.0.0.011355.00.00.00.00.0UNF:6:2jUh8AubANfzHkKM1ZS7lw==ID0.00.00.05120.00.0.0.00.0UNF:6:KR+FyhCsnj6ODpFlHULLXg==NameNaN0.0NaN.5120.0NaNNaNNaNUNF:6:Apn3V6haGq1svhrSsO2pJQ==Gene NameNaNNaNNaNNaNNaN5120.0.0.0UNF:6:Apn3V6haGq1svhrSsO2pJQ==GenBank Protein ID0.0.5120.00.00.00.00.00.0UNF:6:KR+FyhCsnj6ODpFlHULLXg==GenBank Gene IDNaNNaNNaN0.0NaNNaN5120.0.UNF:6:Apn3V6haGq1svhrSsO2pJQ==UniProt ID.NaNNaNNaN5120.00.0NaNNaNUNF:6:Apn3V6haGq1svhrSsO2pJQ==Uniprot TitleNaNNaNNaNNaN0.0NaN5120.0.UNF:6:Apn3V6haGq1svhrSsO2pJQ==PDB ID.0.0NaNNaNNaN5120.0NaNNaNUNF:6:Apn3V6haGq1svhrSsO2pJQ==GeneCard ID0.0NaNNaN5120.0NaNNaN.NaNUNF:6:Apn3V6haGq1svhrSsO2pJQ==GenAtlas ID5120.0NaNNaNNaNNaN0.0.NaNUNF:6:Apn3V6haGq1svhrSsO2pJQ==HGNC IDNaN0.0NaN5120.0NaNNaN.NaNUNF:6:Apn3V6haGq1svhrSsO2pJQ==SpeciesNaNNaNNaNNaN5120.00.0.NaNUNF:6:Apn3V6haGq1svhrSsO2pJQ==Drug IDsNaNNaNNaNNaN5120.0.0.0NaNUNF:6:Apn3V6haGq1svhrSsO2pJQ==ID0.00.00.00.00.00.0.1256.0UNF:6:PJZHTS9Qde4FyxeGpF3qfQ==Name1256.0NaN0.0NaN.NaNNaNNaNUNF:6:/XCeuZ3BnTEG46NJQqC1YA==Gene Name0.0NaN.1256.0NaNNaNNaNNaNUNF:6:/XCeuZ3BnTEG46NJQqC1YA==GenBank Protein ID0.00.01256.00.00.0.0.00.0UNF:6:PJZHTS9Qde4FyxeGpF3qfQ==GenBank Gene IDNaN.1256.0NaNNaNNaNNaN0.0UNF:6:/XCeuZ3BnTEG46NJQqC1YA==UniProt IDNaNNaN1256.0NaN0.0.NaNNaNUNF:6:/XCeuZ3BnTEG46NJQqC1YA==Uniprot Title.NaNNaN0.01256.0NaNNaNNaNUNF:6:/XCeuZ3BnTEG46NJQqC1YA==PDB IDNaN.1256.0NaN0.0NaNNaNNaNUNF:6:/XCeuZ3BnTEG46NJQqC1YA==GeneCard IDNaNNaN0.0.NaN1256.0NaNNaNUNF:6:/XCeuZ3BnTEG46NJQqC1YA==GenAtlas IDNaNNaN0.0NaN1256.0.NaNNaNUNF:6:/XCeuZ3BnTEG46NJQqC1YA==HGNC ID0.0.NaNNaNNaNNaNNaN1256.0UNF:6:/XCeuZ3BnTEG46NJQqC1YA==Species1256.00.0NaNNaNNaN.NaNNaNUNF:6:/XCeuZ3BnTEG46NJQqC1YA==Drug IDsNaN0.0NaN1256.0NaNNaNNaN.UNF:6:/XCeuZ3BnTEG46NJQqC1YA==structureIdUNF:6:spZ07Q7m5YdTorQcI6QvMg==authorsUNF:6:iHECryIWt1JGvEst9q/yiA==publicationYear0.0.8.8560740161232052010.0120686.024900.02018.02009.0579851846962UNF:6:TgvjL3ZirMJk7MFiI+OVjw==titleUNF:6:9E1urN589szmxgzFhZiLWA==journalNameUNF:6:DRtO0jApVaQxEequ+mx3yg==volumeIdUNF:6:+99GfBQOD0a0aXnvm0J+yQ==firstPageUNF:6:EjF2qH5lu0CJq1yo95KPzw==lastPageUNF:6:fqM+Lz8y310LRknuOZ2u7g==pubmedId2.1094607E7117771.027815.02.016163786417924E72.9741882E75.0.6352898.198012639UNF:6:XmQSFKvRvRApA4gx+eDc0A==pmcUNF:6:JOPJ0CfcTn9i3DfJOU71Sw==doiUNF:6:YGO3e5LLAr2HMG2U0N8rnQ==structureIdUNF:6:943AoBGGaGmUUywiYrZV6Q==chainIdUNF:6:1fbwa7c1MlriRNG+TNdu3w==entityId.0.04.75225391860844991.010.7431636319369781.0429807.01.0UNF:6:xVRZpPDTkLcjCPwfC0FneQ==clusterNumber1004563.032889.0.67020.011813.966554798702396918.01.015609.582324114106UNF:6:TjeVYZB3ODVwc4BbAvBIWw==clusterNumber951.08558.0734559731211938.82927384227932889.02940.0396918.054215.0.UNF:6:TgZ9I1YXi8bb13DFSyK/oQ==clusterNumber9032889.07899.684914768714.396918.051390.011158.221935388081.02651.0UNF:6:H3n01PjK12AEn6qnj+u5Cw==uniprotAccUNF:6:uP+ON0JOP+0fX16RJMSG5A==uniprotRecommendedNameUNF:6:H6UIVLEH+0cyzUStG4MKfA==uniprotAlternativeNamesUNF:6:pujF9TYHIpjWE7wqhOMQQw==geneNameUNF:6:nSo1LfTrYzOQoSpcKtIXEQ==authorAssignedEntityNameUNF:6:tbZ5ASqxoQ9oD+jF4hye2A==synonymUNF:6:GOmRzf/p7p75Qj4RsbltMQ==taxonomyUNF:6:upO+usjuhDwmIYFUvwGHuw==taxonomyIdUNF:6:Uv7dcA+hpbFaSyRSNc3cmQ==structureIdUNF:6:LUJwnrDDWhA5g0so8+EwRw==deviceUNF:6:ckKYMl6jTA+OztrkwjN65w==diffractionSourceUNF:6:hWdEmvWvjUnCejax9W5g7g==collectionDateUNF:6:JQpG9w+3AtYbLg7eUzqwyg==collectionTemperature.51.698349026037334100.0123536.0115.961845615837691400.013531.01.0UNF:6:tQOmJ9KiCyopY7BOHo1CJw==structureIdUNF:6:Fj0ZHbzBQhgEyDQ5+5sZaQ==rObserved0.035118535.00.03415997620606306413301.00.97.0.19536216307419740.194UNF:6:Mo8m+J4fm9zdU685J8cVWQ==rAll0.199608139388072870.017108075.01.16923761.00.0393016202758425.0.198UNF:6:HT1AxishuGFBfSjxiSdPkg==rWork.0.033770573559456306126927.04909.00.194866907750123860.0420.1930.615UNF:6:wcrgNMNxzwTX8HIm7tfJHg==rFree7722.0.0.2360.049124114.00.5160.235975949530270430.0393557523674627UNF:6:XD4Ap46XgspVfgGpXYy8ww==averageBFactor37.78244337708995.27.5245040150462795147.0-13.7636689.0696.130.88UNF:6:a+F7gjMg4ys4Mp2hQXA9yA==refinementResolution2.07767.02.200751054787933670.0.0.481.1543708645205406131069.0UNF:6:Qb/JLk04y9Y1QRXi2gD+lQ==structureIdUNF:6:IP2GEmZzoH5yMAXIsUtgjQ==highResolutionLimit2.2013536168676335131281.0850.070.02.071.1544724127937342.0.48UNF:6:03iAAH5UkVf8eSRvlNyTYw==reflectionsForRefinement127787.01.5015304E757738.2410182678533146.0.138983.74954654964344.00.0UNF:6:hH66WqvUOhg3S86PKnJSoQ==structureDeterminationMethodUNF:6:pZxh/bwYI2NYfpBCvcywYA==structureIdUNF:6:knNbD6en7DxXOkpvmq0ymg==origChainIdUNF:6:ahZbrTB/aFA9LAX8kjYkRw==entityId1.0.5.3971576285185791.011.3796860830329610.0163.0490717.0UNF:6:lB4O570lS5fOYL9C0o2Vqg==db_codeUNF:6:SHAM7Mh9vCnoM0NfERtk/A==db_nameUNF:6:+c5hMNHFCF/i9Tk2a62HVg==sequenceUNF:6:wjS5l9QDrNIQyIWvAqhDwA==chainLength1.0203.05070.00.0263.26143932527845490717.0.248.38850090780178UNF:6:fNK4X0LMTp680tannNgw0w==molecularWeight158.1790.059265.96324097551641910.022973.8.30613.250154936333490717.0UNF:6:0Rzl9fLIr0J5HarKz3uYvQ==entityMacromoleculeTypeUNF:6:nonyFqvoa7E1x/cHqLGb7g==structureIdUNF:6:luyght8MPbMzScybj9BOCA==structureTitleUNF:6:R3XPlI0M+zdbt1bUo2k7mQ==experimentalTechniqueUNF:6:clywTQwhhPNdiprNY2vCVw==ndbIdUNF:6:aPNsG7T04p95StXbAHUw0w==resolution2.2640487983297.70.012939.0131234.00.482.091.404899836868882UNF:6:Itut/j0i/ZnWCGARd4tnMw==classificationUNF:6:9zdS2jLhktEJ1eoRCTaNJA==releaseDateUNF:6:K3ZyMsw3eAMbLwUaQJkdYg==depositionDateUNF:6:V+ojzIX0Tu4EqyarHWlLfA==revisionDateUNF:6:+iJ55sI4JZtLhMzrQrd+Jw==authorsUNF:6:sH5tjQwJQqeDSSUuxKcxPg==structureMolecularWeight144173.0314.38.47656.2617138.51395718220.0113072.197831286299.7730536E7UNF:6:/vX4tAHWjN0ZhK5R71Uj1Q==macromoleculeTypeUNF:6:lpX3DTr5WGz2NMcpNoBVfw==residueCount0.0313236.00.0828.4346098086216416.02125.357475585923144173.0.UNF:6:2ETIdEU7TKFPRO3B69EX2g==atomSiteCount.0.02440800.020062.011805543173162.0144173.06674.8308976043480.0UNF:6:zEoexNa4R6SGwnHJ8I3Ayw==pdbDoiUNF:6:tml4aX0dvUYEdjxFMtlOuw==structureIdUNF:6:WvhikHzLfuYITd91kcdBeA==100 quantiles of stk_cites_nslf31.029.82617580684232212306.049.048.71046643913557100.08128.0.UNF:6:ucuCLZCfGmwnBbAjpXuY2A==Predicted values.16.284296035766644.95837448015938520434.045.2422561645507813.567828882560503100.00.0UNF:6:KZvMZxXHGJDVP/GY+3anwQ==structureIdUNF:6:82r46ocbTcgdHzlaYdiqCQ==UNF:6:orG/Sx4CP7NfW4u+YCTXLQ==UNF:6:MY/PxEyxCZN6l5tG6hgFoA==10410.00.0.18.56532874087992490.0100.050.082.12968299711812UNF:6:8+Ql+8AX0e8KpB6QilUmMA==10410.00.52315081652257471.00.49948774347449610.00.0.1.0UNF:6:wzYUK4KEfAubejfxBAq2zw==0.00.4953898101916001710410.00.00.00.432084534101827231.0.UNF:6:YjtcRPSpmgde/G74S8+56A==StartDateUNF:6:Fq382ybCoi8fZ1I2mM3NhQ==EndDateUNF:6:e8ewniTtIV04wpuymjC7OQ==StatusUNF:6:i8abDc7RsTMXu+XM1NWzHw==Progress.31.455044093234157100.013.083.292313517605690.0100.010564.0UNF:6:nz5Qp3byclLDs/yk5khpRQ==Duration (in seconds)1296175.00.010564.040987.48748777706172.00.04654.944433927156.UNF:6:Gk/8nGg3GOQVEgF5eWIPJg==FinishedUNF:6:sSj4xgIBNzuQvu7weC1O+A==RecordedDateUNF:6:t90+R+sIHwSQ+w6HSEEryQ==ResponseIdUNF:6:pkpvWXR5hNiQ0QAvrfdrHw==DistributionChannelUNF:6:V69H/UzPRZmeluqISbNCbA==UserLanguageUNF:6:DK1fZsfUMbmT0AFns/jH+A==Q_BallotBoxStuffingUNF:6:WEEH5CZZoPjvOGfRKSxVNQ==Comp 1.1_126.127423682869014585.05979.061.00.0100.058.889640130861466.UNF:6:U71CtFSf4EV5dT9Mw96jpw==Comp 2.1_152.659551530832270.04638.026.0510664205742235926.0100.0.50.0UNF:6:y19RdK5SvG64SbgOq1vCDA==Qual 1.1_10.036373.012.9197112860892396.8216624166435712.024.0.4191.0UNF:6:UEZmCv1sp5sjzSciLLQ8ZQ==Qual 1.2_1UNF:6:PdrPcLlBLYJnkDk1/JDoxw==Qual 1.2_2UNF:6:YB30WG/JXuuuyw9bSiV6wQ==Qual 1.2_3UNF:6:uiTACON2yY2jy6lC4MinEA==Qual 1.2_4UNF:6:cjQc6iT0SLqnmqv45Oz9bg==Qual 1.2_5UNF:6:QLBKGCv8JnnamTHhjmqycg==Qual 1.2_6UNF:6:ofKcoeKfuqGQ4lLPjEiw/w==Qual 2.1_10.08.116514.024.06.5261039588822439.935474074074072.4050.0UNF:6:/60j05skv+H4+rcKZOWCew==Qual 2.2_1UNF:6:I/K7A7Z7epJqudw3ojnPDQ==Qual 2.2_2UNF:6:1d/wX5w+4iGRSYKO5rBjNg==Qual 2.2_3UNF:6:kX2lvgfJai68OzGSbJmJlQ==Qual 2.2_4UNF:6:80roXj8Kkl5FSx9xqpMSUA==Qual 2.2_5UNF:6:y0x+ZvMdp7wR1PD7DewELg==Qual 2.2_6UNF:6:YNdTqD8ItFWdrv9JSIbxcQ==D1UNF:6:5XfCcA+nqh+fWoTeFWg90w==D2UNF:6:oSX/OtAWifh6swatvLLrIw==D3UNF:6:goItuaOO62BZrBAr+3zbWQ==l0_l1UNF:6:Yu0JxnSNjkroo7vV4js91w==pubmedId604016.01279434.01.5058693831709042E70.02.9735985E7.1.5299625E76093502.081918616UNF:6:yzzR3xLpbrT8PXChGVztdw==0.01980.02010.8980242245045.2018.0604016.02012.05.900052985882172UNF:6:t+0X6nblJRaHqThDr7DJKQ==(sum) nbcites0.00.0604016.0.0.00.00.00.0UNF:6:zjA6dzErhaR0PeT/hnMWsA==(sum) nbcites_nslf0.00.00.0.604016.00.00.00.0UNF:6:zjA6dzErhaR0PeT/hnMWsA==.2018.0604016.01980.06.8477547236692832004.02003.7960484490240.0UNF:6:/E0pfR+M+YsSvv5Sc16+Xg==0.00.00.0.0.00.00.0604016.0UNF:6:zjA6dzErhaR0PeT/hnMWsA==0.00.00.00.00.00.0604016.0.UNF:6:zjA6dzErhaR0PeT/hnMWsA==.0.0604016.00.00.00.00.00.0UNF:6:zjA6dzErhaR0PeT/hnMWsA==0.0604016.00.00.00.0.0.00.0UNF:6:zjA6dzErhaR0PeT/hnMWsA==01_build_pdb.doapplication/x-stata-syntax01_clean_summary.doapplication/x-stata-syntax01_summary_stats.doapplication/x-stata-syntax02_build_entities.doapplication/x-stata-syntax02_clean_citation.doapplication/x-stata-syntax02_potential_regressions.doapplication/x-stata-syntax03_build_structures.doapplication/x-stata-syntax03_clean_refine.doapplication/x-stata-syntax03_structural_genomics.doapplication/x-stata-syntax04_build_papers.doapplication/x-stata-syntax04_clean_collection.doapplication/x-stata-syntax04_competition_regressions.doapplication/x-stata-syntax05_clean_entity.doapplication/x-stata-syntax05_define_sample.doapplication/x-stata-syntax05_welfare.doapplication/x-stata-syntax06_clean_pubmed.doapplication/x-stata-syntax06_generate_p.doapplication/x-stata-syntax06_welfare_calculations.doapplication/x-stata-syntax07_appendix_misc.doapplication/x-stata-syntax07_clean_validation.doapplication/x-stata-syntax08_clean_drugbank.doapplication/x-stata-syntax08_phat_bootstrap.doapplication/x-stata-syntax09_clean_survey.doapplication/x-stata-syntax09_survey_analysis.doapplication/x-stata-syntaxcomp_qual_master.doapplication/x-stata-syntaxpdbe_Validation.csvtext/csvplaceholder.csvtext/csvREADME.pdfapplication/pdfTables.xlsxapplication/vnd.openxmlformats-officedocument.spreadsheetml.sheetuniprot_pubmed.dtaapplication/x-stata-14