{"@context":{"@language":"en","@vocab":"https://schema.org/","citeAs":"cr:citeAs","column":"cr:column","conformsTo":"dct:conformsTo","cr":"http://mlcommons.org/croissant/","rai":"http://mlcommons.org/croissant/RAI/","data":{"@id":"cr:data","@type":"@json"},"dataType":{"@id":"cr:dataType","@type":"@vocab"},"dct":"http://purl.org/dc/terms/","examples":{"@id":"cr:examples","@type":"@json"},"extract":"cr:extract","field":"cr:field","fileProperty":"cr:fileProperty","fileObject":"cr:fileObject","fileSet":"cr:fileSet","format":"cr:format","includes":"cr:includes","isLiveDataset":"cr:isLiveDataset","jsonPath":"cr:jsonPath","key":"cr:key","md5":"cr:md5","parentField":"cr:parentField","path":"cr:path","recordSet":"cr:recordSet","references":"cr:references","regex":"cr:regex","repeated":"cr:repeated","replace":"cr:replace","sc":"https://schema.org/","separator":"cr:separator","source":"cr:source","subField":"cr:subField","transform":"cr:transform","wd":"https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/"},"@type":"sc:Dataset","conformsTo":"http://mlcommons.org/croissant/1.0","name":"Replication data for: New Empirical Strategies for the Study of Parliamentary Government Formation","url":"https://doi.org/10.7910/DVN/HJCPDK","creator":[{"@type":"Person","givenName":"Garrett","familyName":"Glasgow","affiliation":{"@type":"Organization","name":"University of California, Santa Barbara"},"name":"Garrett Glasgow"},{"@type":"Person","givenName":"Matt","familyName":"Golder","affiliation":{"@type":"Organization","name":"Pennsylvania State University"},"name":"Matt Golder"},{"@type":"Person","givenName":"Sona","familyName":"N. Golder","affiliation":{"@type":"Organization","name":"Pennsylvania State University"},"name":"Sona N. Golder"}],"description":"In recent years a consensus has developed that the conditional logit (CL) model is the most appropriate strategy for modeling government choice. In this paper, we reconsider this approach and make three methodological contributions. First, we employ a mixed logit with random coefficients that allows us to take account of unobserved heterogeneity in the government formation process and relax the independence of irrelevant alternatives (IIA) assumption. Second, we demonstrate that the procedure used in the literature to test the IIA assumption is biased against finding IIA violations. An improved testing procedure reveals clear evidence of IIA violations, indicating that the CL model is inappropriate. Third, we move beyond simply presenting the sign and significance of model coefficients, suggesting various strategies for interpreting the substantive influence of variables in models of government choice.","keywords":[],"license":"http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0","datePublished":"2011-12-27","dateModified":"2014-10-02","includedInDataCatalog":{"@type":"DataCatalog","name":"Harvard Dataverse","url":"https://dataverse.harvard.edu"},"publisher":{"@type":"Organization","name":"Harvard Dataverse"},"version":"2.0","citeAs":"@data{DVN/HJCPDK_2011,author = {Garrett Glasgow and Matt Golder and Sona N. Golder},publisher = {Harvard Dataverse},title = {Replication data for: New Empirical Strategies for the Study of Parliamentary Government Formation},year = {2011},url = {https://doi.org/10.7910/DVN/HJCPDK}}","citation":[{"@type":"CreativeWork","name":"Glasgow, Garrett, Matt Golder, and Sona N. Golder. 2012. \"New Empirical Strategies for the Study of Parliamentary Government Formation.\" Political Analysis (Spring 2012) 20 (2): 248-270. article available here"}],"distribution":[{"@type":"cr:FileObject","@id":"domparcf.do","name":"domparcf.do","encodingFormat":"text/x-stata-syntax; charset=US-ASCII","md5":"48b519e66963e321e4f13128316b84f9","contentSize":"3813","description":"Creates data for largest party counterfactual.  Run this before running Figure1.do or Figure3a.do.","contentUrl":"https://dataverse.harvard.edu/api/access/datafile/:persistentId?persistentId=doi:10.7910/DVN/HJCPDK/2HAWXT"},{"@type":"cr:FileObject","@id":"Figure1.do","name":"Figure1.do","encodingFormat":"text/x-stata-syntax; charset=US-ASCII","md5":"5a3bc2ff356ef1c55fc7b1e81c8dedfd","contentSize":"5027","description":"Creates Figure 1.","contentUrl":"https://dataverse.harvard.edu/api/access/datafile/:persistentId?persistentId=doi:10.7910/DVN/HJCPDK/Y2K6GG"},{"@type":"cr:FileObject","@id":"Figure2.do","name":"Figure2.do","encodingFormat":"text/x-stata-syntax; charset=US-ASCII","md5":"c493d987d0a8b4421cedf133c543d19d","contentSize":"2785","description":"Creates Figure 2.","contentUrl":"https://dataverse.harvard.edu/api/access/datafile/:persistentId?persistentId=doi:10.7910/DVN/HJCPDK/LIDMKV"},{"@type":"cr:FileObject","@id":"Figure3a.do","name":"Figure3a.do","encodingFormat":"text/x-stata-syntax; charset=US-ASCII","md5":"85f261df2b17c26bc6801f944f40cbdd","contentSize":"1370","description":"Creates Figure 3a.","contentUrl":"https://dataverse.harvard.edu/api/access/datafile/:persistentId?persistentId=doi:10.7910/DVN/HJCPDK/7PIQD2"},{"@type":"cr:FileObject","@id":"Figure3b.do","name":"Figure3b.do","encodingFormat":"text/x-stata-syntax; charset=US-ASCII","md5":"a473148bb075f9f129fad9ad441476cb","contentSize":"1775","description":"Creates Figure 3b.","contentUrl":"https://dataverse.harvard.edu/api/access/datafile/:persistentId?persistentId=doi:10.7910/DVN/HJCPDK/1BZPUJ"},{"@type":"cr:FileObject","@id":"Figure4.do","name":"Figure4.do","encodingFormat":"text/x-stata-syntax; charset=US-ASCII","md5":"64a6a502959bc38be7ade5e0ef978014","contentSize":"462","description":"Creates Figure 4.","contentUrl":"https://dataverse.harvard.edu/api/access/datafile/:persistentId?persistentId=doi:10.7910/DVN/HJCPDK/CIKAH7"},{"@type":"cr:FileObject","@id":"Figure5.do","name":"Figure5.do","encodingFormat":"text/x-stata-syntax; charset=US-ASCII","md5":"98c00f355e4792638d6c73c8961e2e70","contentSize":"10790","description":"Creates Figure 5.","contentUrl":"https://dataverse.harvard.edu/api/access/datafile/:persistentId?persistentId=doi:10.7910/DVN/HJCPDK/79ZR7B"},{"@type":"cr:FileObject","@id":"formation_new.dta","name":"formation_new.dta","encodingFormat":"application/x-stata","md5":"9923ce5b79ea7441f071664a92ba1d78","contentSize":"10106709","description":"Government formation data (from Martin and Stevenson, 2001 AJPS).","contentUrl":"https://dataverse.harvard.edu/api/access/datafile/:persistentId?persistentId=doi:10.7910/DVN/HJCPDK/J7UCRU&format=original"},{"@type":"cr:FileObject","@id":"mixlpred2.ado","name":"mixlpred2.ado","encodingFormat":"text/plain; charset=US-ASCII","md5":"d2f4577ce2effbe04912da08abd093fa","contentSize":"3272","description":"Stata ado file for mixed logit predictions.  Install with user written ado files.","contentUrl":"https://dataverse.harvard.edu/api/access/datafile/:persistentId?persistentId=doi:10.7910/DVN/HJCPDK/4BAZMG"},{"@type":"cr:FileObject","@id":"procf.do","name":"procf.do","encodingFormat":"text/x-stata-syntax; charset=US-ASCII","md5":"d7df79d60b88bb3b6c317da68d3db5b1","contentSize":"1732","description":"Creates data for pre-electoral coalition counterfactual.  Run this before running Figure3b.do.","contentUrl":"https://dataverse.harvard.edu/api/access/datafile/:persistentId?persistentId=doi:10.7910/DVN/HJCPDK/MWW0CE"},{"@type":"cr:FileObject","@id":"Table1.do","name":"Table1.do","encodingFormat":"text/x-stata-syntax; charset=US-ASCII","md5":"6744874ba3b4386c8e176dc13819e07f","contentSize":"3535","description":"Creates Table 1, including specification test.","contentUrl":"https://dataverse.harvard.edu/api/access/datafile/:persistentId?persistentId=doi:10.7910/DVN/HJCPDK/BOYAFH"},{"@type":"cr:FileObject","@id":"Table2.do","name":"Table2.do","encodingFormat":"text/x-stata-syntax; charset=US-ASCII","md5":"67a1cd8a1bc07f0151ac48b6a40a275e","contentSize":"9005","description":"Creates Table 2.","contentUrl":"https://dataverse.harvard.edu/api/access/datafile/:persistentId?persistentId=doi:10.7910/DVN/HJCPDK/VAJ82Q"}],"recordSet":[{"@type":"cr:RecordSet","field":[{"@type":"cr:Field","name":"case","description":"","dataType":"sc:Float","source":{"@id":"13636717","fileObject":{"@id":"formation_new.dta"},"extract":{"column":"case"}}},{"@type":"cr:Field","name":"country","description":"","dataType":"sc:Float","source":{"@id":"13636733","fileObject":{"@id":"formation_new.dta"},"extract":{"column":"country"}}},{"@type":"cr:Field","name":"formopp","description":"","dataType":"sc:Float","source":{"@id":"13636692","fileObject":{"@id":"formation_new.dta"},"extract":{"column":"formopp"}}},{"@type":"cr:Field","name":"seats","description":"","dataType":"sc:Float","source":{"@id":"13636693","fileObject":{"@id":"formation_new.dta"},"extract":{"column":"seats"}}},{"@type":"cr:Field","name":"realg","description":"","dataType":"sc:Float","source":{"@id":"13636686","fileObject":{"@id":"formation_new.dta"},"extract":{"column":"realg"}}},{"@type":"cr:Field","name":"gdiv1","description":"","dataType":"sc:Float","source":{"@id":"13636708","fileObject":{"@id":"formation_new.dta"},"extract":{"column":"gdiv1"}}},{"@type":"cr:Field","name":"mgodiv1","description":"","dataType":"sc:Float","source":{"@id":"13636739","fileObject":{"@id":"formation_new.dta"},"extract":{"column":"mgodiv1"}}},{"@type":"cr:Field","name":"minor","description":"","dataType":"sc:Float","source":{"@id":"13636754","fileObject":{"@id":"formation_new.dta"},"extract":{"column":"minor"}}},{"@type":"cr:Field","name":"median","description":"","dataType":"sc:Float","source":{"@id":"13636718","fileObject":{"@id":"formation_new.dta"},"extract":{"column":"median"}}},{"@type":"cr:Field","name":"minwin","description":"","dataType":"sc:Float","source":{"@id":"13636701","fileObject":{"@id":"formation_new.dta"},"extract":{"column":"minwin"}}},{"@type":"cr:Field","name":"dompar","description":"","dataType":"sc:Float","source":{"@id":"13636755","fileObject":{"@id":"formation_new.dta"},"extract":{"column":"dompar"}}},{"@type":"cr:Field","name":"sq","description":"","dataType":"sc:Float","source":{"@id":"13636736","fileObject":{"@id":"formation_new.dta"},"extract":{"column":"sq"}}},{"@type":"cr:Field","name":"prevpm","description":"","dataType":"sc:Float","source":{"@id":"13636689","fileObject":{"@id":"formation_new.dta"},"extract":{"column":"prevpm"}}},{"@type":"cr:Field","name":"mcw3","description":"","dataType":"sc:Float","source":{"@id":"13636726","fileObject":{"@id":"formation_new.dta"},"extract":{"column":"mcw3"}}},{"@type":"cr:Field","name":"minran2","description":"","dataType":"sc:Float","source":{"@id":"13636730","fileObject":{"@id":"formation_new.dta"},"extract":{"column":"minran2"}}},{"@type":"cr:Field","name":"mginvest","description":"","dataType":"sc:Float","source":{"@id":"13636756","fileObject":{"@id":"formation_new.dta"},"extract":{"column":"mginvest"}}},{"@type":"cr:Field","name":"anmax2","description":"","dataType":"sc:Float","source":{"@id":"13636711","fileObject":{"@id":"formation_new.dta"},"extract":{"column":"anmax2"}}},{"@type":"cr:Field","name":"pmdist","description":"","dataType":"sc:Float","source":{"@id":"13636699","fileObject":{"@id":"formation_new.dta"},"extract":{"column":"pmdist"}}},{"@type":"cr:Field","name":"pmport","description":"","dataType":"sc:Float","source":{"@id":"13636688","fileObject":{"@id":"formation_new.dta"},"extract":{"column":"pmport"}}},{"@type":"cr:Field","name":"vsp","description":"","dataType":"sc:Float","source":{"@id":"13636746","fileObject":{"@id":"formation_new.dta"},"extract":{"column":"vsp"}}},{"@type":"cr:Field","name":"msp","description":"","dataType":"sc:Float","source":{"@id":"13636737","fileObject":{"@id":"formation_new.dta"},"extract":{"column":"msp"}}},{"@type":"cr:Field","name":"psp","description":"","dataType":"sc:Float","source":{"@id":"13636703","fileObject":{"@id":"formation_new.dta"},"extract":{"column":"psp"}}},{"@type":"cr:Field","name":"singpar","description":"","dataType":"sc:Float","source":{"@id":"13636697","fileObject":{"@id":"formation_new.dta"},"extract":{"column":"singpar"}}},{"@type":"cr:Field","name":"warmiss","description":"","dataType":"sc:Float","source":{"@id":"13636712","fileObject":{"@id":"formation_new.dta"},"extract":{"column":"warmiss"}}},{"@type":"cr:Field","name":"pmpodi","description":"","dataType":"sc:Float","source":{"@id":"13636741","fileObject":{"@id":"formation_new.dta"},"extract":{"column":"pmpodi"}}},{"@type":"cr:Field","name":"vspsing","description":"","dataType":"sc:Float","source":{"@id":"13636734","fileObject":{"@id":"formation_new.dta"},"extract":{"column":"vspsing"}}},{"@type":"cr:Field","name":"msppsp","description":"","dataType":"sc:Float","source":{"@id":"13636713","fileObject":{"@id":"formation_new.dta"},"extract":{"column":"msppsp"}}},{"@type":"cr:Field","name":"mwgdiv1","description":"","dataType":"sc:Float","source":{"@id":"13636729","fileObject":{"@id":"formation_new.dta"},"extract":{"column":"mwgdiv1"}}},{"@type":"cr:Field","name":"gdiv1c","description":"","dataType":"sc:Float","source":{"@id":"13636702","fileObject":{"@id":"formation_new.dta"},"extract":{"column":"gdiv1c"}}},{"@type":"cr:Field","name":"pmgdvdif","description":"","dataType":"sc:Float","source":{"@id":"13636720","fileObject":{"@id":"formation_new.dta"},"extract":{"column":"pmgdvdif"}}},{"@type":"cr:Field","name":"numpar","description":"","dataType":"sc:Float","source":{"@id":"13636747","fileObject":{"@id":"formation_new.dta"},"extract":{"column":"numpar"}}},{"@type":"cr:Field","name":"anti","description":"","dataType":"sc:Float","source":{"@id":"13636691","fileObject":{"@id":"formation_new.dta"},"extract":{"column":"anti"}}},{"@type":"cr:Field","name":"pro","description":"","dataType":"sc:Float","source":{"@id":"13636749","fileObject":{"@id":"formation_new.dta"},"extract":{"column":"pro"}}},{"@type":"cr:Field","name":"newid","description":"","dataType":"sc:Float","source":{"@id":"13636745","fileObject":{"@id":"formation_new.dta"},"extract":{"column":"newid"}}},{"@type":"cr:Field","name":"equal1","description":"","dataType":"sc:Float","source":{"@id":"13636714","fileObject":{"@id":"formation_new.dta"},"extract":{"column":"equal1"}}},{"@type":"cr:Field","name":"pmdisneq","description":"","dataType":"sc:Float","source":{"@id":"13636716","fileObject":{"@id":"formation_new.dta"},"extract":{"column":"pmdisneq"}}},{"@type":"cr:Field","name":"gdiv1neq","description":"","dataType":"sc:Float","source":{"@id":"13636719","fileObject":{"@id":"formation_new.dta"},"extract":{"column":"gdiv1neq"}}},{"@type":"cr:Field","name":"single","description":"","dataType":"sc:Float","source":{"@id":"13636722","fileObject":{"@id":"formation_new.dta"},"extract":{"column":"single"}}},{"@type":"cr:Field","name":"pspmsp","description":"","dataType":"sc:Float","source":{"@id":"13636738","fileObject":{"@id":"formation_new.dta"},"extract":{"column":"pspmsp"}}},{"@type":"cr:Field","name":"mspsing","description":"","dataType":"sc:Float","source":{"@id":"13636740","fileObject":{"@id":"formation_new.dta"},"extract":{"column":"mspsing"}}},{"@type":"cr:Field","name":"pfull1","description":"","dataType":"sc:Float","source":{"@id":"13636724","fileObject":{"@id":"formation_new.dta"},"extract":{"column":"pfull1"}}},{"@type":"cr:Field","name":"pmw1","description":"","dataType":"sc:Float","source":{"@id":"13636709","fileObject":{"@id":"formation_new.dta"},"extract":{"column":"pmw1"}}},{"@type":"cr:Field","name":"pmed1","description":"","dataType":"sc:Float","source":{"@id":"13636725","fileObject":{"@id":"formation_new.dta"},"extract":{"column":"pmed1"}}},{"@type":"cr:Field","name":"pgdiv1","description":"","dataType":"sc:Float","source":{"@id":"13636704","fileObject":{"@id":"formation_new.dta"},"extract":{"column":"pgdiv1"}}},{"@type":"cr:Field","name":"pnp1","description":"","dataType":"sc:Float","source":{"@id":"13636690","fileObject":{"@id":"formation_new.dta"},"extract":{"column":"pnp1"}}},{"@type":"cr:Field","name":"pmin1","description":"","dataType":"sc:Float","source":{"@id":"13636735","fileObject":{"@id":"formation_new.dta"},"extract":{"column":"pmin1"}}},{"@type":"cr:Field","name":"pinv1","description":"","dataType":"sc:Float","source":{"@id":"13636721","fileObject":{"@id":"formation_new.dta"},"extract":{"column":"pinv1"}}},{"@type":"cr:Field","name":"pbig1","description":"","dataType":"sc:Float","source":{"@id":"13636694","fileObject":{"@id":"formation_new.dta"},"extract":{"column":"pbig1"}}},{"@type":"cr:Field","name":"psq1","description":"","dataType":"sc:Float","source":{"@id":"13636742","fileObject":{"@id":"formation_new.dta"},"extract":{"column":"psq1"}}},{"@type":"cr:Field","name":"ppm1","description":"","dataType":"sc:Float","source":{"@id":"13636695","fileObject":{"@id":"formation_new.dta"},"extract":{"column":"ppm1"}}},{"@type":"cr:Field","name":"pant1","description":"","dataType":"sc:Float","source":{"@id":"13636750","fileObject":{"@id":"formation_new.dta"},"extract":{"column":"pant1"}}},{"@type":"cr:Field","name":"ppro1","description":"","dataType":"sc:Float","source":{"@id":"13636710","fileObject":{"@id":"formation_new.dta"},"extract":{"column":"ppro1"}}},{"@type":"cr:Field","name":"pneg1","description":"","dataType":"sc:Float","source":{"@id":"13636700","fileObject":{"@id":"formation_new.dta"},"extract":{"column":"pneg1"}}},{"@type":"cr:Field","name":"popp1","description":"","dataType":"sc:Float","source":{"@id":"13636728","fileObject":{"@id":"formation_new.dta"},"extract":{"column":"popp1"}}},{"@type":"cr:Field","name":"preif","description":"","dataType":"sc:Float","source":{"@id":"13636696","fileObject":{"@id":"formation_new.dta"},"extract":{"column":"preif"}}},{"@type":"cr:Field","name":"prebg","description":"","dataType":"sc:Float","source":{"@id":"13636751","fileObject":{"@id":"formation_new.dta"},"extract":{"column":"prebg"}}},{"@type":"cr:Field","name":"coal","description":"","dataType":"sc:Float","source":{"@id":"13636732","fileObject":{"@id":"formation_new.dta"},"extract":{"column":"coal"}}},{"@type":"cr:Field","name":"vspcoal","description":"","dataType":"sc:Float","source":{"@id":"13636698","fileObject":{"@id":"formation_new.dta"},"extract":{"column":"vspcoal"}}},{"@type":"cr:Field","name":"mspcoal","description":"","dataType":"sc:Float","source":{"@id":"13636687","fileObject":{"@id":"formation_new.dta"},"extract":{"column":"mspcoal"}}},{"@type":"cr:Field","name":"prels","description":"","dataType":"sc:Float","source":{"@id":"13636727","fileObject":{"@id":"formation_new.dta"},"extract":{"column":"prels"}}},{"@type":"cr:Field","name":"prelsod","description":"","dataType":"sc:Float","source":{"@id":"13636748","fileObject":{"@id":"formation_new.dta"},"extract":{"column":"prelsod"}}},{"@type":"cr:Field","name":"preod","description":"","dataType":"sc:Float","source":{"@id":"13636744","fileObject":{"@id":"formation_new.dta"},"extract":{"column":"preod"}}},{"@type":"cr:Field","name":"exclude1","description":"","dataType":"sc:Float","source":{"@id":"13636723","fileObject":{"@id":"formation_new.dta"},"extract":{"column":"exclude1"}}},{"@type":"cr:Field","name":"eq1","description":"","dataType":"sc:Float","source":{"@id":"13636706","fileObject":{"@id":"formation_new.dta"},"extract":{"column":"eq1"}}},{"@type":"cr:Field","name":"central","description":"only use this varibale with pmport~=0","dataType":"sc:Float","source":{"@id":"13636731","fileObject":{"@id":"formation_new.dta"},"extract":{"column":"central"}}},{"@type":"cr:Field","name":"counform","description":"","dataType":"sc:Integer","source":{"@id":"13636752","fileObject":{"@id":"formation_new.dta"},"extract":{"column":"counform"}}},{"@type":"cr:Field","name":"govt","description":"","dataType":"sc:Text","source":{"@id":"13636705","fileObject":{"@id":"formation_new.dta"},"extract":{"column":"govt"}}},{"@type":"cr:Field","name":"invest","description":"","dataType":"sc:Float","source":{"@id":"13636753","fileObject":{"@id":"formation_new.dta"},"extract":{"column":"invest"}}},{"@type":"cr:Field","name":"election","description":"","dataType":"sc:Float","source":{"@id":"13636715","fileObject":{"@id":"formation_new.dta"},"extract":{"column":"election"}}},{"@type":"cr:Field","name":"govtnum","description":"","dataType":"sc:Integer","source":{"@id":"13636707","fileObject":{"@id":"formation_new.dta"},"extract":{"column":"govtnum"}}},{"@type":"cr:Field","name":"pec","description":"","dataType":"sc:Float","source":{"@id":"13636743","fileObject":{"@id":"formation_new.dta"},"extract":{"column":"pec"}}}]}]}